1. Maya - Obviously a smokeshow with some interesting character development fleshed out so early on
2. Josy - Pretty much perfect except for the obvious. Her relation to Tommy should make for interesting stuff going forward. If she is Chads side chick that would be even better from a story perspective but would drop her down.
3. Sage - Fun personality and presents an obvious key point for striking against Chad.
4. Jill - Reminds me a lot of Pinky from Bully as the nice prep girl who is relatively hot. A lot more character development and focus would help.
5. Isabella - Hot, but still distinctively unlikable. Could change with more focus. Seems a bit older for the game's college frat theme but to each their own.
6. Riona - Kind of a sex bomb but tied up with shady ass Quinn.
7. Cathy - the femdom stuff is cool but she is ancillary at best
8. Camilla - Just not doing it for me
9. Jade - literally a trope of sex positive feminist academics who fit a certain fantasy; nothing wrong with that though if it works for you
10. Quinn - Pimp and Drug dealer who probably is responsible for diseases and shit