That and they're unable to grasp the idea that people chose different decisions when they were presented. Not all DIK characters jumped on every woman that spread her legs. In fact, my main DIK run I specifically chose every option that would lower my relations with Maya/Josy, yet since it's a game they were still foisted off on me from the get go. It's not the fault of the player that Josy throws herself at him minutes into the game, then proceeds to admit she's in a relationship and just cheated. That first makeout scene, happens no matter what you choose. There are further examples of this in the Josy/Maya storyline going from there.
Yet, people screech that the MC is a hypocrite! Uh, not even if you're making him sleep around, because he's NOT in a relationship with anyone. We can say he's a douche if he sleeps around, playing with the emotions of the girls, but you can be 100% honest with them. That in no way is similar to what Josy/Maya did in the game from the get go. Regardless, I don't hate either of them, I just don't like them and the way Josy was presented from the start made it so she was unrecoverable to me. Maya was better, but her continued fuck ups kept lowering her appeal to me. She screws up, apologizes, then proceeds to fuck up, only to apologize again. No one can act like they would be okay with what she was a part of at the end of Episode 1.