Not really, MC is a single guy and free to pursue or mess around with any girl who he (us players) so chooses to. He was
not in a relationship with neither Josy or Maya like they were with each other. When he tells Jill about Maya & Josy she's able to understand and tolerate his story because he's single and free to see other women, but condemns anyone doing so while already in relationship.
As for their developing relationship
right as significant progress was made with Maya but before their's could go another level the whole Josy bombshell gets dropped on him.
View attachment 529341