snelly

Newbie
Apr 29, 2017
34
207
Jesus Christ, coming back here after a couple days and I have to read through that incest shit yet again. It's not gonna happen Patreon, Steam and the fact that he wants to be taken seriously(as stated in the intro) are just a few reasons.

Switching topics a bit what do you guys think about the Jill Josy friendship. It's mentioned in their bios and theres a comment on roster by Jill that she wants to show Josy something.

Also it would be fun if theres a little family reunion at Jills piano concert. I imagine MC going there beeing looked down upon by Tybald and his Melonfuckers. Then the granddad recognizes MC because if you're rich you can easily keep track of your relatives even if you want nothing to do with them. Theres a picture of a faceless little fat man in episode one if I remember it correctly.
 

Bod33k

New Member
Dec 1, 2017
11
36
I have another topic for discussion which might have been here already but I did not go through all 2600 pages of this topic...
Don't you think that the MC is overreacting in ch4. I mean:

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
And during the whole ch4 he is:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
What I'm saying is that the first thing that comes to mind when faced with such a revelation begins with "three" and ends with "some". What is he so broken down about? Is it the fact that they hid the truth from him so harmful? For me this would be a dream come true situation. Is he really so feminine or am I just too old or have watched too many porn movies?
Also what would have changed if he knew the truth from the beginning?
Maybe the problem is that they're bisexual?
If I would have been in his shoes I would hug them both and start undressing, thanking heavens for this in the meantime.
 

Goblin Baily: DILF

Conversation Conqueror
Sep 29, 2017
7,319
15,650
Just because it has not been mentioned in the game so far does not necessarily mean it could not have been. Thinking about twists and plots and pondering them is not flat out dumb. And I would appreciate it if you could be more civilized about it ... if that is possible for you of course ..
While it's possible, I don't think James is superdad simply for the fact Bella married James...however it's possible that MC's dad had a fling with Envy...
 

M.Sato

Active Member
Jul 4, 2018
573
3,475
from a purely writing standpoint he could be branching Jill out from just Bella/MC so he has more flexibility to write her into scenes.

Jill was always kinda insular and hard to work into the larger story. Giving her screen time was tricky (which shows in Ep 1-3) and she was very MC-centric. Make her friends with Josy and suddenly she has reasons to crop up in the story more that doesn’t require writing a dedicated scene some people might miss if they bomb out of her route (which you seem to be able to do if you go DIK and tell her you’re bad news).

Flexibility in a story aiming for this many variables is always good. Jill and Josy being buddies puts her in the plot more firmly because her only link to 80% of the cast is the MC.
At first glance, you can close Maya, Josy and Jill routes in ep4; Bella on ep3; and Sage on ep2(?). I wonder if the "main plot" includes any of the girls at all. :unsure:

Jesus Christ, coming back here after a couple days and I have to read through that incest shit yet again. It's not gonna happen Patreon, Steam and the fact that he wants to be taken seriously(as stated in the intro) are just a few reasons.

Switching topics a bit what do you guys think about the Jill Josy friendship. It's mentioned in their bios and theres a comment on roster by Jill that she wants to show Josy something.

Also it would be fun if theres a little family reunion at Jills piano concert. I imagine MC going there beeing looked down upon by Tybald and his Melonfuckers. Then the granddad recognizes MC because if you're rich you can easily keep track of your relatives even if you want nothing to do with them. Theres a picture of a faceless little fat man in episode one if I remember it correctly.
:WaitWhat::WaitWhat::WaitWhat: Can I offer you some ice cold warm beer? :KEK:
 

Mormont

Devoted Member
Nov 30, 2018
11,925
53,085
I have another topic for discussion which might have been here already but I did not go through all 2600 pages of this topic...
Don't you think that the MC is overreacting in ch4. I mean:

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
And during the whole ch4 he is:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
What I'm saying is that the first thing that comes to mind when faced with such a revelation begins with "three" and ends with "some". What is he so broken down about? Is it the fact that they hid the truth from him so harmful? For me this would be a dream come true situation. Is he really so feminine or am I just too old or have watched too many porn movies?
Also what would have changed if he knew the truth from the beginning?
Maybe the problem is that they're bisexual?
If I would have been in his shoes I would hug them both and start undressing, thanking heavens for this in the meantime.
How old is the MC again18-19? I can get the sulking around but the thing is he probably hasn't been in many situations like this before if at all so he probably doesn't know how to react. Most of us in his position would go okay fine I need to take my mind off this with lots of beers and a trip to the strippers perhaps. But as I said the MC is at that age where he hasn't yet matured properly to handle such situations.
 

Bod33k

New Member
Dec 1, 2017
11
36
How old is the MC again18-19? I can get the sulking around but the thing is he probably hasn't been in many situations like this before if at all so he probably doesn't know how to react. Most of us in his position would go okay fine I need to take my mind off this with lots of beers and a trip to the strippers perhaps. But as I said the MC is at that age where he hasn't yet matured properly to handle such situations.
Why would you take your mind of this? What is so bad about this situation? To me it's like winning a lottery.
 

Tserriednich'sNen

Engaged Member
Jan 16, 2020
2,253
6,060
Jesus Christ, coming back here after a couple days and I have to read through that incest shit yet again. It's not gonna happen Patreon, Steam and the fact that he wants to be taken seriously(as stated in the intro) are just a few reasons.

Switching topics a bit what do you guys think about the Jill Josy friendship. It's mentioned in their bios and theres a comment on roster by Jill that she wants to show Josy something.

Also it would be fun if theres a little family reunion at Jills piano concert. I imagine MC going there beeing looked down upon by Tybald and his Melonfuckers. Then the granddad recognizes MC because if you're rich you can easily keep track of your relatives even if you want nothing to do with them. Theres a picture of a faceless little fat man in episode one if I remember it correctly.
MC will definitely be at that concert/talent show whatever it is in support of Jill and I Imagine Tybalt will be there as well. I can see a scenario where after her performance she goes over to MC and Tybalt catches them being all lovey dovey and a unhealthy amount of jealously and hate consumes Ty. Maybe even an option to further agitate him by getting a lil extra with Jill.
 

Goblin Baily: DILF

Conversation Conqueror
Sep 29, 2017
7,319
15,650
How old is the MC again18-19? I can get the sulking around but the thing is he probably hasn't been in many situations like this before if at all so he probably doesn't know how to react. Most of us in his position would go okay fine I need to take my mind off this with lots of beers and a trip to the strippers perhaps. But as I said the MC is at that age where he hasn't yet matured properly to handle such situations.
Not only is he young but he grew up without a mother, he was bullied and his only relationship simply burned out... he has the right to overreact
 

mindern

Active Member
Jul 7, 2017
542
2,224
Why would you take your mind of this? What is so bad about this situation? To me it's like winning a lottery.
Its great if you just wanna get laid but if the MC actually cared about these girls it’s a clusterfuck.

Both of them can’t be trusted. If the MC were to actually fall in love with Maya/Josy and try for a three way relationship he’d have to accept they lied repeatedly to each other, and him, for personal gain. Plus if someone cheats with you, chances are they’ll cheat on you.

The situation is great if you just want sex but an actual non-porn plot relationship with them is fundamentally tainted. Theyre liars. They continued to be liars right up until the MC told the truth. For all of Ep4 Maya and Josy were together and neither deigned to tell the other about why the MC was upset.
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: Joermundgand

name88 - King of Hearts

Engaged Member
Jul 5, 2017
2,422
15,618
Why would you take your mind of this? What is so bad about this situation? To me it's like winning a lottery.
Once feelings(for one or both parties)get involved the perspective changes,especially in case of Maya who did let the MC believe she was single,after reading Mormont `s post I can see how that could be a shock,I still think MC was over-reacting...for the drama`s sake
 

Tserriednich'sNen

Engaged Member
Jan 16, 2020
2,253
6,060
I don't think MC overreacted imo some males would have reacted much worse than how he did. Given his backstory and lack of experience in dealing with relationships his reaction to the whole situation was justified. After he tells both Maya & Josy that he wants some time to think about it all they keep walking up to him pressing him about it, if I were MC that would have only made me more pissed off.
 
4.80 star(s) 1,553 Votes