Hmmm, I am not necessarily disappointed in the characters but rather more disappointed in how it all unfolded. The MC felt like a third wheel as soon as Josy showed up. It is obvious that Maya and Josy are into each other and have chemistry. The MC feels like someone who they turned to in an emotional moment not a real deep connection. He doesn't seem to be someone that will be with them for very long and I was advocating for an entire end to his relationship with them instead of the "friendship" route. How can he suddenly not be bitter at how that turned out? The girl he had a crush on for an entire summer and his new college romance turn out not only to be in committed relationships and cheating (which he knew and he should be leery of committing to them - once a cheater, etc) but they are in a committed relationship with each other and he's supposed to be completely cool with it. Yes, he is sleeping with everyone he can but he can be upfront with them about seeing the two of them (though the player can choose not to do so).
Anyway, it is interesting to see how people perceive the same thing differently.
