felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,551
22,429
IMHO and really just my opinion here,

I can totally understand the "retcon" of the library scene in ep.5.
I don't know about you guys, but is it really that farfetched that even after saying "I just want to be friends" there is still emotional baggage still in the air?

And Josy and Mayas reaction especially are very relatable.
Josy feels like she had no choice to hang on to the friendship even though she clearly had feelings for the MC. So once the friendship was offered she latched on to it since not doing so would potentially mean she would have lost Maya and MC.
Maya was also always attracted to MC and the talk in the room afterwards where MC pledges his loyalty can understandably be confusing, considering the fact they were almost lovers about 2-4 days (!) ago.

The only inconsistent factor is the MC since it is a projected character of yourself, so I get that some people already ended their relationship with Maya and Josy after Chapter 4 library scene (Some even before) in their head, but I absolutely do understand why Maya/Josy/MC act and think that way in chapter 5. It's just almost impossible to get closure after 1 day.
Even though I do see, why people think that it is off.
it's a strong scene but it develops in a way we never expected.

the girls press MC because he gives them an opportunity to explain themself, in the end MC gives it to them, but he is the one who explains himself, or rather, to solve the problems between the 2 girls ...

the "let's be friends" option does not make any sense, but it is the safety net if the proposal is rejected, it must be accepted in this light.

I absolutely don't think it's a wrong scene, it's consistent with the MC character, who is a Masochistic Samaritan
 

xsssssssss

Active Member
Jun 17, 2017
815
1,049
for example: when MC is at Josy's dinner, he can decide whether to stay or go home. the choice makes sense, if we focus on Maya we may not want to betray her, Josy then at that moment seems to be going away.
I agree that 99% of players will choose to stay, it's a porn game and we play for that.

but if you choose to leave, Josy will be punished by her parents anyway, so she will be without a phone and will not be able to notify Maya.

what is that choice for? just delete it, nobody would complain about it.

this situation has led me, but I think many players, to follow 2 paths: always look for lewd scenes, or play in defense. both possibilities kill roleplay enough
Well I disagree, that choice is very important. The player, i for one wouldn’t want to be railroaded into a sex scene. That’s quite a difference from the odd fixed kiss. A choice still has merit from a role playing perspective. It is the forced dinner date anyway that leads to the forced Josy punishment.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ename144

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,551
22,429
Well I disagree, that choice is very important. The player, i for one wouldn’t want to be railroaded into a sex scene. That’s quite a difference from the odd fixed kiss. A choice still has merit from a role playing perspective. It is the forced dinner date anyway that leads to the forced Josy punishment.
but that Josy is punished for bringing a boy to the parents' room is credible, that she is punished for having dined with someone less ...

how does it make an important choice if it doesn't make any difference afterwards?

it's not that if you don't have sex with Josy, Maya will give you credit later ....
 

AvatarStormBringer

Well-Known Member
Dec 20, 2019
1,213
1,262
The problem here is that MC is overly good to them even after friendzoning them. After kicking them to the curb, he's giving them the wrong impression and signal that he still cares, thus confusing them.

As I told someone before, there is no such thing as regarding a female as "friend" for a male, especially attractive ones. For a male to befriend a female, the female has to attract the male first for him to even consider it.

I am not sure about the culture in this game, but the relationship development from first met -> attracted -> sex -> break up -> get back together -> make up sex -> threesome in 2 weeks in warp speed in my books.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zirael Q

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,551
22,429
The problem here is that MC is overly good to them even after friendzoning them. After kicking them to the curb, he's giving them the wrong impression and signal that he still cares, thus confusing them.

As I told someone before, there is no such thing as regarding a female as "friend" for a male, especially attractive ones. For a male to befriend a female, the female has to attract the male first for him to even consider it.

I am not sure about the culture in this game, but the relationship development from first met -> attracted -> sex -> break up -> get back together -> make up sex -> threesome in 2 weeks in warp speed in my books.
it is clear that MC has not given up, he clearly tells Josy (after doing it as a porter) and she reciprocates by stabbing him and saying that she is convinced that they would have been happy together ...


MC may be friend with Maya (difficult but possible), for a matter of gratitude, for having hosted him when he had nowhere to stay, but with Josy in no alternative reality ...
 

Zirael Q

Well-Known Member
Aug 28, 2017
1,616
9,555
The problem here is that MC is overly good to them even after friendzoning them. After kicking them to the curb, he's giving them the wrong impression and signal that he still cares, thus confusing them.

As I told someone before, there is no such thing as regarding a female as "friend" for a male, especially attractive ones. For a male to befriend a female, the female has to attract the male first for him to even consider it.

I am not sure about the culture in this game, but the relationship development from first met -> attracted -> sex -> break up -> get back together -> make up sex -> threesome in 2 weeks in warp speed in my books.
Well, my MC certainly didn't care about their problems, on my main route didn't see their scenes at all. It wouldn't make sense otherwise tbh
 

Rinbael

Well-Known Member
Sep 7, 2018
1,357
3,636
I just wonder how the scavenger hunt will be handled if you friend zone Maya and Josy are they still going to ask the MC for help? I know they plan to fake it but I don't see Quinn falling for it especailly since she doesn't like Maya and she can't afford more sisters joining.
 

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,551
22,429
I just wonder how the scavenger hunt will be handled if you friend zone Maya and Josy are they still going to ask the MC for help? I know they plan to fake it but I don't see Quinn falling for it especailly since she doesn't like Maya and she can't afford more sisters joining.
the girls are likely to ask MC for help (as friends are credible), not sexually ..

but the real question is whether the free tuition is real or not.

I take it for granted that Maya passes the scavenger hunt, but not that she gets the free tuition
 
  • Like
Reactions: imzahai

lemonfreak

The Freakiest of Lemons
Oct 24, 2018
5,552
10,286
the girls are likely to ask MC for help (as friends are credible), not sexually ..

but the real question is whether the free tuition is real or not.

I take it for granted that Maya passes the scavenger hunt, but not that she gets the free tuition
There was talk of using a dildo for the blowjob task and as for the sex outdoors and threesome tasks, well, it doesn't say anywhere that there needs to be a man involved does it? :BootyTime:
 

Rinbael

Well-Known Member
Sep 7, 2018
1,357
3,636
There was talk of using a dildo for the blowjob task and as for the sex outdoors and threesome tasks, well, it doesn't say anywhere that there needs to be a man involved does it? :BootyTime:
I just don't see Maya agreeing to have sex outdoors and the threesome I suppose they will fake it with a dildo but I don't see Quinn being dumb enough to fall for it especially since she doesn't like Maya.
 

lemonfreak

The Freakiest of Lemons
Oct 24, 2018
5,552
10,286
I just don't see Maya agreeing to have sex outdoors and the threesome I suppose they will fake it with a dildo but I don't see Quinn being dumb enough to fall for it especially since she doesn't like Maya.
I meant getting another girl (Lily for example), 3 people is 3 people, regardless of gender. Loopholes ftw.

And for outside, they could use the garden at the HOTs sorority house.
 

Rinbael

Well-Known Member
Sep 7, 2018
1,357
3,636
I meant getting another girl (Lily for example), 3 people is 3 people, regardless of gender. Loopholes ftw.

And for outside, they could use the garden at the HOTs sorority house.
True but I know on the Maya Josy path they mention Lily and Ashley were also going to fake the tasks. I suppose Camila could help Maya and Josy but I still don't see Maya having sex outside or agreeing to a threesome so I guess their only option is to fake it.
 

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,551
22,429
There was talk of using a dildo for the blowjob task and as for the sex outdoors and threesome tasks, well, it doesn't say anywhere that there needs to be a man involved does it? :BootyTime:
you're right, but Maya loses all her hair if Quinn finds out she likes the pussy
 

sohabit

New Member
May 22, 2020
13
3
Guys,i know it's wrong but can you please spoiler me a bit what happended in e5? Can not play due to some reason but i can not wait to know. Thank you!
 
4.80 star(s) 1,553 Votes