- Dec 13, 2018
- 7,748
- 19,529
Because it's a common thing in English to refer to a singular person as "they", like if someone were ask, "Where's X?" and the answer was, "They're in the kitchen"; it's only one person, but you can refer to them as "they".why refer DPC as 'they' when its hinted in the thread often that he is a solo artist/creator?
I agree, what Jill does with this situaion is indeed inconsistent.no, it doesn't work like that
apart from that I don't understand what would be the legitimate reasons that should convince me that I'm wrong not to be satisfied with a scene ....
I have already explained why Jill's behavior FOR ME is not consistent.
for a person with Jill's strong morality, willing to go against what MC had explicitly told him in order to report Chad's attack, it is not coherent to hide a crime without first understanding the situation. she theoretically believes that MC started a fire in a house full of people ....
Does Jill blindly believe in Tybalt? possible, then it should be she who does not want to have anything to do with MC (who with her gesture put at risk the piano she cares so much about)
and love and age have nothing to do with it, she covers up Mc's "crime" even if they're just friends (because of MC's bad behavior)
here too, what would the legitimate reasons be?
that I didn't understand the scene, and I didn't understand the character
perfect and reasonable
In Ep 3, the MC flat-out tells Jill that he's not being bullied by Chad and the Jocks and to not do anything about what just happened, but she does anyway because she believes it's the right thing to do. But here we have her blindly accept Tybalt's account of what happened that night and agrees to sit back and let him talk to the other Preps about not filing charges (yeah, right ). The Jill from Ep 3 doesn't seem like someone who would just sit back and do nothing, she'd either not do as Tybalt says and would go talk to some of the Preps herself because she wants to know the full story, or she would ask the MC outright if what Tybalt says is true.
Considering she wanted to resolve that issue of the "bullying", I see no reason why she wouldn't also want to resolve the issue with Tybalt. What seems more Jill is if she went and spoke to some of the other Preps to get an idea of what happened, they all gave her conflicting accounts with several of them not even naming the MC, and so Jill then resolves to get the MC and Tybalt in a room together to hash out what really happened.
It does seem as though, once again, the forced drama of the story is making characters behave in a way that doesn't seem to line up with what we've seen of them so far.