- Dec 13, 2018
- 7,748
- 19,532
He is not "clearly dead", there's 2 instances of inner monologue from Bella where it seems very clear that he is very much alive and that they have separated because of something both of them did which Bella both forgives him for and hopes he has forgiven her for.Why do people think James is going to come back? He's clearly dead or something but she feels like starting a new relationship would be cheating on his memory. Probably a military man MIA in some conflict which would explain a lot he's dead but she's in denial. The whole "I'd call for help" line about Bella suggests there is something wrong with her not a simple James walked out on her sort of thing.
This sounds more like a case of mutual cheating, likely him first, then her, and the reason she's so cagey about doing these things with the MC to begin with is because she feels she's betraying James again even though they are separated.