CREATE YOUR AI CUM SLUT ON CANDY.AI TRY FOR FREE
x

godkingxerxes

Engaged Member
Sep 27, 2020
2,176
5,976
" I just don't think it's quite as large and omnipresent a flaw as you do."

No you wouldn't, you guys have bought this game hook, line, and sinker. And if that's what you like, more power to you.

The whole point of my criticism of this game, and it's creator, is that it's not a good game, it's just a really well marketed one. That makes BaDIK the AVN equivalent of the worst kind of mainstream drivel, no creativity, no depth, no soul.
If this isn't a good game, what is the standard of good? How many games at one time can be considered good?

It's like saying JF Caron isn't a good strongman because he's never won World's Strongest Man.
 

DavDR

Engaged Member
Oct 14, 2020
2,019
3,301
Right, and my point is BaDIK *is* a good game, with strengths that more than compensate for the very real flaws it does have.

The game's never going to be for everyone and I have no problem with people who don't like it. But frankly I see no indication that it's soulless or devoid of creativity. Whatever DPC is, he isn't the AVN equivalent of Michael Bay cranking out Transformers sequels.
From about the third or fourth season BaDIK has given me an unmistakable Game of Thrones vibe.

The worst thing though is the over the top devotion that BaDIK fan's have for the game. Yes the music is good, but many other games have good music. Yes, there are some excellent renders in the game but there's also some really awful ones and overall the quality is inconsistent at best. The animations are mediocre. The characters are compelling but in fact are basically stock characterizations. The worst part though is that having gotten the player hooked on the characters DPC doesn't know what to do with them, the story is the fatal flaw in the game.
 

always86

Active Member
Mar 19, 2020
897
2,316
" I just don't think it's quite as large and omnipresent a flaw as you do."

No you wouldn't, you guys have bought this game hook, line, and sinker. And if that's what you like, more power to you.

The whole point of my criticism of this game, and it's creator, is that it's not a good game, it's just a really well marketed one. That makes BaDIK the AVN equivalent of the worst kind of mainstream drivel, no creativity, no depth, no soul.
I completely disagree with you.

Out of interest can you name 3 AVNs that you think are objectivly better? I think I can guess one or maybe 2 you will say but can't imagine a way BaDIK wouldn't be in anyones top 5.

I'm not quite sure how any AVN could be 'mainstream' but i'd imagine that is a personal opinion on the genre's that you like. To say it has no depth is simply not ture. From a pure plot POV there is a somehwat complex narrative around drugs, prostitution, and school politics. It has a huge cast of characters who all have thier own personalities, many of whom have interpersonal relationships outside of that with the MC. On a simple mechanics level it has more going on that any other VN i've played (before you poo-poo this please give some examples of games with more mechanics that are implemented at least as well).

I find it very strange that you would argue the game has no soul. I can't think of an AVN with a world that feels as alive as BaDIK. Again can you give some examples of games you think
 

shazba

Engaged Member
Aug 4, 2020
3,506
19,697
See, how long did it take you to write all of that? If my opinions upset you so much why don't you just ignore them?
Au contraire, I love talking about this game, so you just give me more opportunity for me to write what I like about it.

Everytime when shazba write something tldr
View attachment 1283355
I know what you mean, when I see other people's posts that aren't even half the size of mine I just glaze over and can't get myself to read them.

It does surprise me sometimes how many people can be be bothered reading what I write, but my ego tells me my posts are highly insightful and entertaining, so it all makes sense. :p
 
Last edited:

SpearOfReigns

Member
Nov 8, 2017
459
1,166
The whole point of my criticism of this game, and it's creator, is that it's not a good game, it's just a really well marketed one.
Ah yes, as we all know Dr. Pinkcake and his great marketing strategy such as
*squints*
Banning low tier patrons from discord for discussing new update before their supposed release date
Threatening to launch a barrage of DMCA claim & close a subreddit if he isn't given authority
Banning $75 tier patron for leaking custom render

If anything, this game is popular & a success in spite of the "marketing". Shows how good it really is
 

Pi Quantum

Member
Jan 19, 2021
162
371
Sarah: She's not even pretty, but there's definitely something about her.
Agree with most of your points, but particularly this one. I wasn't much of a Sarah fan until the scene in Gender Studies where she tells Maya the blunt truth, but she really grew on me after that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: yeesssss

vogelbeest

Engaged Member
Jan 9, 2021
2,008
2,866
If anything, this game is popular & a success in spite of the "marketing". Shows how good it really is
DPC only needs a few guys to regularly write here BADIK is trash and we see plenty responses saying his game is great...
In a marketing point of view DPC must love to have a few bashing his work when they have over fifty or hundred posts in this thread, there's no better proof their messages are meaningless, you need just 1 post to write a game is bad....
 
Last edited:

Nattrack

Newbie
Jul 2, 2021
85
97
If this isn't a good game, what is the standard of good? How many games at one time can be considered good?

It's like saying JF Caron isn't a good strongman because he's never won World's Strongest Man.
This game is good, but just because 99% of porn-erotic games are pure crap, the same way a shard of glass shines like a diamond among pebbles. But that doesn't make a shard of glass a diamond. If we compare this game with TV, this is a juvenile Disney-channel soap-opera mixed with "National Lampoon's Animal House", not "The Sopranos".
 
  • Like
Reactions: CynicalBstrd

DavDR

Engaged Member
Oct 14, 2020
2,019
3,301
Ah yes, as we all know Dr. Pinkcake and his great marketing strategy such as
*squints*
Banning low tier patrons from discord for discussing new update before their supposed release date
Threatening to launch a barrage of DMCA claim & close a subreddit if he isn't given authority
Banning $75 tier patron for leaking custom render

If anything, this game is popular & a success in spite of the "marketing". Shows how good it really is
Have you ever heard of controversy marketing? Hollywood has been doing it for a while now. DPC uses it quite effectively.

If you read far enough into this forum you will learn that at one time DPC posted here, but according to some people he was driven away from the forum by trolls and critics. Personally I think that was his intention all along.
 

godkingxerxes

Engaged Member
Sep 27, 2020
2,176
5,976
This game is good, but just because 99% of porn-erotic games are pure crap, the same way a shard of glass shines like a diamond among pebbles. But that doesn't make a shard of glass a diamond. If we compare this game with TV, this is a juvenile Disney-channel soap-opera mixed with "National Lampoon's Animal House", not "The Sopranos".
Yeah I was going to add that comparing AVNs with top of the line video games, they obviously fall short.

But I didn't think anyone was looking at those games as a standard for "good".

As I said this sort of argument is similar to the silly cunts out there that say LeBron James sucks because he isn't Michael Jordan .

And yes, your TV description is accurate but in this universe there is no Sopranos.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CynicalBstrd

Nattrack

Newbie
Jul 2, 2021
85
97
And yes, your TV description is accurate but in this universe there is no Sopranos.
Well, in this universe there are great games in terms of story and characters, only not porn ones. We know what is real quality in games . But one thing is true: the dev is trying to make a juvenile soap-opera mixed with "National Lampoon", and that's exactly what he delivers. He's not trying to make "The Sopranos". It´s just that some people here think that "Being a DIK" is "The Sopranos".
 
Last edited:

hyfka

Active Member
Mar 8, 2021
548
824
He's not trying to make "The Sopranos". It´s just that some people here think that "Being a DIK" is "The Sopranos".
This. The charcters, story, writing, minigames are decent. Not great, really just meh.
But in a world where the average porn game story is that all women are perpetally horny nymphos who the MC seduces simply by the power of his magic johnson, this one is quite a welcome exception.
 

godkingxerxes

Engaged Member
Sep 27, 2020
2,176
5,976
Well, in this universe there are great games in terms of story and characters, only not porn ones. We know what is real quality in games . But one thing is true: the dev is trying to make a juvenile soap-opera mixed with "National Lampoon", and that's exactly what he delivers. He's not trying to make "The Sopranos". It´s just that some people here think that "Being a DIK" is "The Sopranos".
But we're talking about the standard of porn games, so we're not counting studio developed games. So even though these games exist, ignore them and only compare BaDIK to other games of its genre.

And I don't think the people here think this game is anywhere near a Sopranos level, the writing is consistently criticized, and short comings are pointed out.

This game is American Pie and all other college based games here are barely Scary Movie.

So while BaDIK isn't best game ever, it's a levels maybe even two above its nearest competitor.

It's not Pinkcakes fault that these other guys can't write a story better than his. Even with this emotional lesbian MC.
 

Kellermann

Engaged Member
Oct 20, 2020
3,630
11,722
If you read far enough into this forum you will learn that at one time DPC posted here, but according to some people he was driven away from the forum by trolls and critics. Personally I think that was his intention all along.
I think DPC genuinely needed/wanted F95 at first, but when the popularity of BaDIK took off, this site quickly outlived its usefulness. Now he actively hates this place and anyone who even mentions it. At this point, he is so successful and wealthy that he does not need to be that proactive with his marketing tactics. F95 still probably does a majority of the marketing for this game even if DPC chooses not to acknowledge the symbiotic relationship.
 

LauLau

New Member
Dec 9, 2017
6
2
Does anyone know how I can change the MC' name in gallery scenes? I know how to change on phone etc. But I'd like to change the name in the scenes only.
 

PashafromRussia

Well-Known Member
Aug 18, 2019
1,557
5,500
I think DPC genuinely needed/wanted F95 at first, but when the popularity of BaDIK took off, this site quickly outlived its usefulness. Now he actively hates this place and anyone who even mentions it. At this point, he is so successful and wealthy that he does not need to be that proactive with his marketing tactics. F95 still probably does a majority of the marketing for this game even if DPC chooses not to acknowledge the symbiotic relationship.
Why would he hate this site? He earns enough money to just ignore the pirates.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RukiRG
4.80 star(s) 1,565 Votes