I honestly can't agree one single bit on that. Josy is so... bland, so... plain. She legit has nothing on for her, literally nothing aside from M&J... and too me that always has been incredible shoed horned by DPC so that Josy could have a role in the story... and its being a plot device in Maya's. IDK, even on episode 1 I was like... meh. Especially after the MC goes to college I legit forgot she existed and I would skip the travel back home and that non GF date if it was possible. She's by far the least interesting LI in what is supposed to be a drama story, my man. Its obviously just my opinion, and I dont wish to have a waifu war.
That is one way to look at it, but I would not dismissing everything that seniorboop said
first of all Badik is foremost a comedy with Drama elements, unlike acting lesson wich was a more Drama focused game. While I agree that Josy seems less developed and may be blank or more specifically just regular, or average. The only Drawback of Josy is truly her connection to Maya, without that Josy alone easily the Best Girlfriend material of all. thanks to the fact, what you find boring
, is that she comes without stupid annoying Drama. She exactly what you get as seniorboop pointed out. She is a hot girl, the typical Girl next Door, who fall in love wiht MC loves the sex wiht him, and can be a stable college couple, everything you would want in real life at this age.
Unlike with the other girls.
Sage, who is obsessed with her ex BF, and can't figure out all this time he is Gay, which is funny considering the Gay jokes she throw at MC if, he not grab her ass, or dont want to fuck her
.
Jill, who literally living in bubble and seemingly have zero idea about real life, and the top of that she has an obsessed Stalker.
Maya, the oppressed girl by her family with the piece of shit father.
Bella, the lonely housewife who hopefully secretly a Dominatrix
.
or Quinn and her companions, who are drug addict, drug dealers, and willing to fuck with anyone who give them money.
compared to them Josy is indeed, the most bland, plain and simple. and Yet as of if right now, - this could easily change, - but seemingly the most Healthy and regular Relationship.
and That is one of the main appeal of her, just a regular hot girl with a regular Main MC living their college life. They Study, the party they having Sex. without all the unnecessary drama, that should not even concern the MC most of the times.
That is Why Josy is the best girl