Ahhhh, when the MC says the same lie it's "small" and "not decisive in anything". That's funny, isn it.
Anyway. For me there are two ways to see this is: either is a plot hole (and a significant one, not like the loan plot) or either the MC act like an hypocrite. Here is my argument:
View attachment 1654682
So, we know for this that the MC is also angry with Josy and blame her for alegdely a fault against him. But why? Even if, by some wierd reason Maya is at fault, why Josy?.
View attachment 1654693
View attachment 1654694
Josy defense is on point, she didn't lied about it and there is no difference if it's a boy or a girl, so why the MC is still angry with her? Let's see his answer.
View attachment 1654704
So, first, the MC acknowledge the gender is not the issue. Great. But wtf is what comes next, "the difference is that it's Maya". Why? Because you are also fucking her? Josy should had tell the MC that her girlfriend is Maya, so the MC would knew that he is also fucking Josy's girl friend while she was fucking Josy? That's so selfish from Josy really...
Plus Josy didn't even knew that the MC was with Maya, so is not only absurdly egocentric but also simple absurdity. At this point the MC has nothign against Josy. Absolutely nothing.
Of couse the MC, so "honest" as usually didn't clarify this, avoid tell Josy (or Maya) that actually he was fucking both of them, and change his argument to:
View attachment 1654711
View attachment 1654712
Now he goes back, he sayds Josy should have told she had a girlfriend, not a boyfriend, even after admiting it wouldn't make a difference and adds another point, she should have told the college her girlfriend was going. He could also have added other useful information like the color heair, tits size, college career and room number to make him knew he eventually was going to fuck her.
And it's not like all thoose information would make a difference. If you don't care that your booty call was in a formal relationship... why would you care if she is actually going to the same college?.
Anyway the guy who is having sex with 19 girls has to know the identity of the guy he is being cuck, otherwise he is being cheat. Bravo.