I feel the hate for The Madame is a very different type of hate compared to the hate for Tybalt.
Tybalt is an intentionally unpleasant cunt. He's designed to be hated, and we hate him for the right reasons. But it's also enjoyable to hate him, and the scenes that he's in are good, even through the cloud of hate.
But the Madame was not created to be hated. You're actually meant to enjoy the mc fucking her, well, almost fucking her. But there was one major miscalculation on DPC's part:
When the mc gets that VIP card, it was anticipated to be access to an-all-you-can-eat Nicole and Lily anal buffet. But those two were nowhere to be seen, and then in walks this oily dugong, and that was just a very sad downgrade.
And so, she is hated for what she is not, and she has never climbed out of that bucket of hate, because she hasn't established herself as anything else.
If she remains a side character that is completely disconnected to every other character in the entire game, and she exists purely as a vanity project for DPC, then she will forever be dubbed the oily manatee.
But... If she
is Priscilla, if she does have a major stake in all of this, then ramming the mc's rod into her intestines is a completely different ballgame; the dynamic will change, she will "become human", and things could actually be interesting.
Right now, she's just boring. And oily.