- Apr 25, 2022
- 2,271
- 7,819
Pretty much this. I've seen people suggest that Jill wants MC to "Change for her". Frankly, that doesn't match up with the dialogue. She's more impressed that MC can be himself in front of his friends. That, to me, suggests the exact opposite of an expectation to change. That's important to her because of her past experiences with Rusty.I always ignore catfish girl on all my plays since it never seemed to lead to anything. MC only vaguely recognizes Micha from Swyper.
Jill most likely had zero interactions with Zoey. She basically interacted with the people she is friendly with, which is understandable. She only got to bond with Sage because of Maya. Jill also wasn't there for truth or drink so she had no clue that Zoey is the MCs ex. The revelation and Jill's jealousy are definitely coming but her not acknowledging Zoey at the end of Ep9 makes sense. The MC doesn't bring Zoey up and Jill doesn't go up to random people unless they are being bullied in front of her.
Bella was there when Josy brings it up during truth or drink but we never see her face as far as I remember. It was kind of weird that there was no acknowledgement on her part that Zoey has re-entered the MCs life.
I don't think Jill wants him to make big changes for her. It's player's choice. MC canon is neutral (one could argue pre-Zoey he was more Chick leaning and post-Zoey more DIK leaning by the time we are introduced to him) and you can get Jill as neutral. If you're a DIK Jill won't get serious with you anyway so it's not really about changing for her is it? I haven't been able to get my current DIK saves to actually get the Jill restaurant rejection so I probably have to do another playthrough to see if the MC holds out hope for her. Unless DPC takes a page from Grease and the MC pulls a Danny to try to "change" for her? But in Grease Danny doesn't actually change in the end, she changes for him. But don't see Jill changing for the MC no matter how much Bianca pushes her out of her shell.
Agree on Zoey not knowing about the birthday feelings. MC tells Sage/Jill he's never told anyone and we know Zoey was worse than Sage with talking about feelings. MC even says to Zoey that he had loads of practice not talking about that kind of stuff with her.
I think the idea that she's "forcing him to change" is kind of a confirmation bias from people who tend to prefer a more DIK affinity playthrough (which like you said, doesn't matter because she rejects DIK affinity anyway). But I agree, MC - by default - leans more toward CHICK affinity by default if you consider the context of Neil's behavior (as well as MC's immense respect for his dad), and MC's behavior prior to going to B&R. In that context, I think Jill is more attracted to OG Tremolo, and she appreciates that he can stay true to himself in front of his friends... Something Rusty was unable to do.
As far as Jill's reaction to Zoey, I'm kind of curious how that will come down in the Jill branch. I think Jill still has some insecurities but at this stage I think she trusts MC enough not to be threatened by Zoey. I don't see Jill being the jealous type. She started dating MC fully aware that he was dating (and fucking) other girls and she still laughed in EP8 when she asked MC about the dick pic in Tybalt's presentation, even when she knows Josy and Sage recognized Tremolo's cock.
So I don't think she's the jealous type. After all, she still befriended Josy even knowing that she was also dating the same guy. I don't think Jill will have negative preconceptions toward Zoey. On a Jill route, I think Jill feels pretty secure in her relationship with MC in EP9. But I feel like there's a new arc coming on the Jill route though, and it's going to have a lot to do with the impending "meet the parents".