Kodek

Well-Known Member
Jun 26, 2017
1,169
1,431
411
That is the thing. You looking at the obvious suspects. perfect diversions.
I was more leaning on the evidence, I have not seen the nerds during the tests leaving their table. But I've seen Ashley do it, which is one of the reasons I said she could be it.

I said Gina just because she does not give a fuck. But could also be because she have a deal with Stephen too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: felicemastronzo

osculim

Well-Known Member
Aug 21, 2019
1,465
1,285
229
Lilly has a point to prove, while I wouldn't put it past her to cheat to prove said point... I actually do not think she needs too.
Sally does not take English or Maths with MC - but as others have pointed out, there may be another class that Sally is in. We do know that characters have to do retakes... Dawe is one of them.

In all honesty there's loads of people it could be.
Dawe is as thick as a brick even if he cheat. He would still fail. From Bella's surprise look during the marking of the tests. I think it should be a student that usually do well. That excludes Dawe immediately. Its Sally usually probably used all those cheats Magnar collected over time and now that she is most likely shunned by him. She does not have that anymore. Now she is trying everything to help herself out including cheating. I highly doubt she was ever super smart.
 

Kodek

Well-Known Member
Jun 26, 2017
1,169
1,431
411
Lilly has a point to prove, while I wouldn't put it past her to cheat to prove said point... I actually do not think she needs too.
Sally does not take English or Maths with MC - but as others have pointed out, there may be another class that Sally is in. We do know that characters have to do retakes... Dawe is one of them.

In all honesty there's loads of people it could be.
But the cheat sheet was in the room the MC was in and not in another room. Even if Sally did retake the class, why would the cheat be in a room she is not in?

This is the reason I don't understand why are you people leaning so heavily on Sally being the cheater here...
 

Chillout1984

Conversation Conqueror
Nov 15, 2020
6,363
5,061
634
But the cheat sheet was in the room the MC was in and not in another room. Even if Sally did retake the class, why would the cheat be in a room she is not in?

This is one reason I don't understand why are you people leaning so heavily on Sally being the cheater here...
1. The cheat sheet had a shitload of tests, not just the one MC did.
2. It's normal that for exams classes are mixed up from their usual groups.

I'm not saying Sally IS the cheater, just why she couldn't be ruled out because she wasn't in MC's class.
 

Kodek

Well-Known Member
Jun 26, 2017
1,169
1,431
411
Dawe is as thick as a brick even if he cheat. He would still fail. From Bella's surprise look during the marking of the tests. I think it should be a student that usually do well. That excludes Dawe immediately. Its Sally usually probably used all those cheats Magnar collected over time and now that she is most likely shunned by him. She does not have that anymore. Now she is trying everything to help herself out including cheating. I highly doubt she was ever super smart.
And that's points even more to Ashley for me. She is usually on top of Bella's class together with Lily and Derek. And we've heard that Lily is too smart to need cheats, Derek does not actually cheat and that dumbass is actually a genius because he can memorize everything.
 

osculim

Well-Known Member
Aug 21, 2019
1,465
1,285
229
But the cheat sheet was in the room the MC was in and not in another room. Even if Sally did retake the class, why would the cheat be in a room she is not in?

This is the reason I don't understand why are you people leaning so heavily on Sally being the cheater here...
Does not mean there was just one exam. Usually here when one group leaves another group takes the exam.
 

Lagunavii

Engaged Member
Oct 11, 2023
2,440
2,647
400
But the cheat sheet was in the room the MC was in and not in another room. Even if Sally did retake the class, why would the cheat be in a room she is not in?

This is the reason I don't understand why are you people leaning so heavily on Sally being the cheater here...
No the Cheat sheet was in the toilet, the Male toilet in fact, so again another hole in the Sally theory, probably a hole in any of the cheaters being girls
 

osculim

Well-Known Member
Aug 21, 2019
1,465
1,285
229
And that's points even more to Ashley for me. She is usually on top of Bella's class together with Lily and Derek. And we've heard that Lily is too smart to need cheats, Derek does not actually cheat and that dumbass is actually a genius because he can memorize everything.
That is the thing what would be the point for the plot if that was the case. Its a big waste of story if Ashley was the cheater. I highly doubt that. Also Bella said Ashley is a top student after marking the tests
 

Kodek

Well-Known Member
Jun 26, 2017
1,169
1,431
411
1. The cheat sheet had a shitload of tests, not just the one MC did.
2. It's normal that for exams classes are mixed up from their usual groups.

I'm not saying Sally IS the cheater, just why she couldn't be ruled out because she wasn't in MC's class.
And I'm asking for the evidence. I'm not denying the possibility, I just want the evidence. MC ended in the exact same room for both tests, proven if you actually use the cheat. Sally was not there in any of the circunstances
 

Kodek

Well-Known Member
Jun 26, 2017
1,169
1,431
411
No the Cheat sheet was in the toilet, the Male toilet in fact, so again another hole in the Sally theory, probably a hole in any of the cheaters being girls
The toilet is the same for everyone in that classroom male or female and it's actually INSIDE the classroom. There's two doors on that room, one is the exit/entrance and the other is the bathroom. I think you need to look at the scene again.
 

Kodek

Well-Known Member
Jun 26, 2017
1,169
1,431
411
That is the thing what would be the point for the plot if that was the case. Its a big waste of story if Ashley was the cheater. I highly doubt that. Also Bella said Ashley is a top student after marking the tests
She was top of her class. Not top of the score board for the tests. Those two things don't necessarely goes hand to hand, plus if Ashley is a cheater, it would explain why she is in the top of her class anyways.

Bella didn't know who was the cheater when she said that as well and she was also drunk as fuck.
 

Kodek

Well-Known Member
Jun 26, 2017
1,169
1,431
411
No the Cheat sheet was in the toilet, the Male toilet in fact, so again another hole in the Sally theory, probably a hole in any of the cheaters being girls
Also here, cohaboring evidence that not only the bathroom is for both M and F, it's also just for the students in that room.
screenshot0022.png
 

osculim

Well-Known Member
Aug 21, 2019
1,465
1,285
229
No the Cheat sheet was in the toilet, the Male toilet in fact, so again another hole in the Sally theory, probably a hole in any of the cheaters being girls
That does not stop anyone from entering. Perfect cover for a girl. Oh it was found in the Guys bathroom. Must be a guy. That is sexist :ROFLMAO:
 

Yellowie The Goldie

Active Member
May 8, 2022
880
1,110
318
1. The cheat sheet had a shitload of tests, not just the one MC did.
2. It's normal that for exams classes are mixed up from their usual groups.

I'm not saying Sally IS the cheater, just why she couldn't be ruled out because she wasn't in MC's class.
It's not Sally, she's the furthest from the suspects. She takes medically prescripted drugs and is apparently able to speak Latin. It's likely that she is simply an average grade student. She shows affinity for learning and understanding due to MC tutoring her in his room, so she's clearly not stupid or a bad academic.

There's not enough reason to suspect her to be cheating while she is at the same time buying drugs to help with academic learning.
 

Chillout1984

Conversation Conqueror
Nov 15, 2020
6,363
5,061
634
It's not Sally, she's the furthest from the suspects. She takes medically prescripted drugs and is apparently able to speak Latin. It's likely that she is simply an average grade student. She shows affinity for learning and understanding due to MC tutoring her in his room, so she's clearly not stupid or a bad academic.

There's not enough reason to suspect her to be cheating while she is at the same time buying drugs to help with academic learning.
I agree. Like I said before, to me Gina is still the most likely suspect to be Anderson.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yellowie The Goldie

Kodek

Well-Known Member
Jun 26, 2017
1,169
1,431
411
Does not mean there was just one exam. Usually here when one group leaves another group takes the exam.
From where I am, exams happen at the same time. Plus, there was not a lot of students taking intro in math or english anyways, a lot of them were not going into the actual lessons like Gina, but I don't think it would need multiple classes.
 

osculim

Well-Known Member
Aug 21, 2019
1,465
1,285
229
It's not Sally, she's the furthest from the suspects. She takes medically prescripted drugs and is apparently able to speak Latin. It's likely that she is simply an average grade student. She shows affinity for learning and understanding due to MC tutoring her in his room, so she's clearly not stupid or a bad academic.

There's not enough reason to suspect her to be cheating while she is at the same time buying drugs to help with academic learning.
There is more than enough reason to suspect her of cheating. She is clearly not doing well and as I said earlier she had access to all those cheats before to give the impression that she is actually smart. She is my contender for the cheater.
 
4.70 star(s) 1,741 Votes