I don't believe it.
It can't be true.
Dead Fish don't do this.
View attachment 4728395
what happend in the future what made her to be a dead fish? must be a big trauma. but now, you have chance to save her from that trauma.
There is no need for them to beat him up. Troy is a jock himself and at the beginning of the game Troy was pretty hostile to MC no matter what you answer. Why would he even try to defend MC's guitar?
need? no need, indeed. troy the asshole who is hostile to mc is a ex jock. the jocks dropped him out.
there is nothing what say troy is defending our guitar.
Why would chad beat him up? During the gym when chad got welcomed back, Chad told off the Jocks to stop messing with Troy as a regular member, not as a president.
What I see in Troy is more like peeling a papaya, he displays a rotten personality but in reality he is a chill guy as we have seen in the gym moments if you decide to treat him well. So it's not out of character if he stood up for the guitar (He also said he liked the tune before switching to asshole mode) and got beat for it. Again this is a theory, so unless we got a concrete flashback its basically interpretation at this point.
the jocks dropped him out. they hate him. well, chad dont hate him. but chad hit another jock when he say something about being a gay. you know, during mc's first meet with Jill. if the jocks teased chad about being gay, he could beat up troy.
i was wondering for a time, the jocks went in the 66(6) room, because of mc or because of troy?
-since the jocks "won" the fight against mc when he met with Jill, they dont have reason to go in 66 room.
-since they are done with troy, they dont have reason to go in 66 room.
and how they know they are searching for 66 room? i never bothered myself too much with it, i just said to myself, it happend to give mc a real good reason for new room searching and start the story.
i think, its fit in dpc's lazy writing.