- Mar 29, 2019
- 2,860
- 18,600
Yeah, I've shared this theory a few times around here and it's the most logical one to me personally and also it fits with DPC's style of writing. Either she miscarried in the past or had a stillborn and due to the trauma such an event that causes to people it created a rift between her and James. It all escalated even further when Bella caught him cheating (She states that she despises adulterers. People usually hate something that has happened to them.) and they separated. There are two things that point to this - James did something and Bella forgave him for it already and at the pool scene, she asks herself if maybe he forgave her for whatever she did.Lostanddamned
Didn't you have a theory that Bella had a child, one that didn't make it? maybe James was or felt somehow responsible for the death of their child so he left
I was playing Episode 4 and noticed a little stool with a mirror next to the bathroom sink, so this theory kinda makes sense
There are things that are difficult to explain with the nursery theory though:
1. What are those boots that we saw underneath the door doing there?
2. If it was a nursery, wouldn't it make sense for Jill to know what it was? So far we've got the impression that she knows something happened, but doesn't know what's behind the door.
3. The night MC stayed over at her house, he sees her unlocking the door at night and looking inside. She's also wearing high heels for some reason. This one is the weirdest of them all and I have no explanation for this one.
But I do hope next episode we get some proper progress with Bella and get some clues about her story at least.