1. toxicity? any relevant examples? or just a bla-bla-bla? She is supportive person and quite kind to everyone, even in situations when she shouldn't be and do so. Look at Becky, Sarah and Mel, Quinn, Sally, Tybalt. That's how toxicity looks.
Josy and Maya's relationship is toxic, both in the way of friendship and relationship. If on the friendship way we see that they are constantly fighting because Josy can't break up with Maya for unknown reasons and is tormented, on the relationship way Josy is constantly jealous of MC of Maya. Maya behaves more calmly.
2. all people are manipulative by the nature. And females especially. It's the nature, it's the reality. She can hardly be called outstanding in doing this. At least when compared to other game characters and LIs. She has her weaknesses and cons, but who doesn't?
I made a note that all female characters in the game are manipulative. The difference is HOW Josy manipulates. Josy cries, she runs away, she plays on the MC's guilt and it's disgusting.
3. What you'll say if she will do it soon or later? We as players can encourage her thoughts regarding her unhappiness with Maya or cool that down. As I said above, the fact that Maya doesn't talk to MC in the same way accused to her personality and because she is introvert. That doesn't mean that Maya can't have or doesn't have a similar thoughts.
Let's just compare what Maya and Josy say on the path of friendship in ep5. That best characterizes these characters.
MC: I know we made a choice and you know what I chose. I chose you two, but you didn't choose me.I followed my heart and now I'm trying to move on. I'm doing what your brother told me. I'm choosing to be happy.
Maya :I know you wanted it...but how could I choose that? I don't get to make my own choices.
MC:What are you even saying? You can choose whatever you want!
Maya:I'm not used to that!And it didn't feel like Josy wanted it...so how could I?I'm not my parents... I don't give up on people I love.And I love Josy...I don't even know what you are......and yet here you're lying with your arms around me, saying those words..
Josy:It's complicated.
MC:Tell me. What is?
Josy:This! All of this!I love Maya...Talking it out with her made it all feel better...but you know I've had a crush on you, too.
How do you make something like that work?How can you feel loving feelings for two people at the same time!?"How can you tell someone you love, while looking into their eyes, that you maybe wanted to try to be with someone else for a while?
MC:You...didn't say any of this last night!
Josy:Couldn't you tell that I was scared!? Didn't you see that in my eyes?
MC:Scared of what!?
Josy:Scared of losing both of you! And it was like I didn't have a choice in it.It was like it was your and Maya's choice.
Maya... She got feelings for you!? A boy! Like, holy fuck!That has to be something real because I've never seen that with her!
Put yourself in my shoes...What would you have done?I felt like I would lose both of you...and be all...all alone.
MC:So you chose her just to have someone? Instead of being honest with yourself.
Josy:...She felt so unsure, so I didn't dare tell her...And when you said that you'd rather stay our friend...
How could I dare to tell you no, in front of her?She was the only one who was certain for me at that moment.
MC:So you chose to stay silent, just to have someone, instead of being honest with yourself?
Josy:I told you it was complicated.But if you chose to be happy... I can do it too.
I will be happy with her...Sniffles But I think I would have been happy with you, too.
First of all, in both cases, MC is being a complete asshole. He manipulates the girls' emotions in these scenes, not allowing them to forget themselves. But if Maya immediately rejects him saying firmly and confidently that she loves Josy and even accuses MC of trying to confuse her, Josy directly says that she could be happy with MC. Which she basically repeats in both ep9 and ep7 when she sleeps over with MC.
Josy saying how you can love two people at the same time...Well we know that's a lie. She doesn't love Maya, she loves the MC. How do we know that? By her behavior in both friendships and relationships.
On the friendship path:
- constant fighting with Maya.
- "what would happen if there was no Maya?"
- Keeps the MC's sweater.
On the relationship path:
- jealous of MC of Maya
Second, there probably won't be a solo path for Maya. Well, that was obvious. Maya's solo will be available as part of J/M.