dontehall2023

Member
Dec 16, 2023
259
288
196
I think all of this speculation here is due to boredom & waiting out the release. The Josy Maya revelation was a surprise because there was no indications that I saw that said they were in a relationship with each other. So to think that there's a chance that the culprit can't be anyone until it's revealed is wasted effort.

James can be dead or alive. There's no hard evidence any way. Same with who MC is related to. There's been nothing to this point that says he's related to Rusty. Or anyone for that matter. The house that Jill's parents live in isn't confirmed to have been MC's mother's house. I may be wrong there but I thought they just said they bought it from a friend.

All of these theories & speculations will be revealed eventually (perhaps). And then we can go back to see what foreshadowing DPC added before the grand reveal. If any.

There's a total of 4 prominent non-white characters in this game. Two are essentially prostitutes, one is a stripper & the 4th can't just be a guy, he has to be a traitor. Very interesting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: StrontiumBob

grey_shadow

Member
May 21, 2022
310
365
131
I hope Sally isn't a virgin. It wouldn't make much sense for Sally to have been in a relationship with Magnar for an undeterminable period & still be a virgin. I know how some people feel about love interests with a sexual history, but can we not have all of the women be virgins.
I got the impression that the Sally/Magnar relationship was more on Sally's side, with Magnar too focused on his studies to notice the body being thrown at him...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Znar26

FalconLover420

Engaged Member
Nov 23, 2020
2,791
3,234
419
But who is making this about race tho? We are discussing at who can be the leak based on their behavior, trust me if it was based on race there would been all the race jokes, statistics and etc.

Primary Leaker => Nick

Possible Leaker => Jacob, Tommy and others.
 

TuckeredOut

Member
Nov 17, 2018
470
1,094
231
I think all of this speculation here is due to boredom & waiting out the release. The Josy Maya revelation was a surprise because there was no indications that I saw that said they were in a relationship with each other. So to think that there's a chance that the culprit can't be anyone until it's revealed is wasted effort.

James can be dead or alive. There's no hard evidence any way. Same with who MC is related to. There's been nothing to this point that says he's related to Rusty. Or anyone for that matter. The house that Jill's parents live in isn't confirmed to have been MC's mother's house. I may be wrong there but I thought they just said they bought it from a friend.

All of these theories & speculations will be revealed eventually (perhaps). And then we can go back to see what foreshadowing DPC added before the grand reveal. If any.

There's a total of 4 prominent non-white characters in this game. Two are essentially prostitutes, one is a stripper & the 4th can't just be a guy, he has to be a traitor. Very interesting.
I'm sure someone will correct me if I'm wrong on either account but I believe the Royce's were told by a family friend about the house being up on the market and needing to be sold quickly and not that they knew who lived there personally. And also I think it was at least insinuated that the photo from the diary was taken at Lynette's house before she was forced to move away.
 

dontehall2023

Member
Dec 16, 2023
259
288
196
But who is making this about race tho? We are discussing at who can be the leak based on their behavior, trust me if it was based on race there would been all the race jokes, statistics and etc.

Primary Leaker => Nick

Possible Leaker => Jacob, Tommy and others.
Okay. Let's assume race has nothing to do with Jacob being the primary suspect of a lot of people here.

Can you give specific example(s) of Jacob doing something suspicious that would indicate he is the traitor at this point in the story? And if possible, can you share a screenshot of the example(s). If not describe the scene & I'll look for it myself.
 

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
13,343
36,483
1,054
I'm sure someone will correct me if I'm wrong on either account but I believe the Royce's were told by a family friend about the house being up on the market and needing to be sold quickly and not that they knew who lived there personally. And also I think it was at least insinuated that the photo from the diary was taken at Lynette's house before she was forced to move away.
Bianca's dad told the Royces about the house, and yeah it's confirmed Lynette's house and Jill's house are one and the same.
 

dontehall2023

Member
Dec 16, 2023
259
288
196
I'm sure someone will correct me if I'm wrong on either account but I believe the Royce's were told by a family friend about the house being up on the market and needing to be sold quickly and not that they knew who lived there personally. And also I think it was at least insinuated that the photo from the diary was taken at Lynette's house before she was forced to move away.
It's insinuated but not confirmed. The house could have belonged to any of the 3 girl's parents. If I'm not mistaken, I thought Lynette's parents were living in the renovated place at the time of the photo. Not entirely sure about this.
 

FalconLover420

Engaged Member
Nov 23, 2020
2,791
3,234
419
Okay. Let's assume race has nothing to do with Jacob being the primary suspect of a lot of people here.

Can you give specific example(s) of Jacob doing something suspicious that would indicate he is the traitor at this point in the story? And if possible, can you share a screenshot of the example(s). If not describe the scene & I'll look for it myself.
Because it has nothing to do with race LOL

You can use the search function and many people have used various examples on what might implicate.

It has much credibility as the Riona is dead argument.
 

dontehall2023

Member
Dec 16, 2023
259
288
196
Because it has nothing to do with race LOL

You can use the search function and many people have used various examples on what might implicate.

It has much credibility as the Riona is dead argument.
I agree it has nothing to do with race. Can you provide any examples of Jacob being suspicious at all in the story to this point to be a suspect? Aside from the face that anyone can be a suspect until it's revealed who they are.
 

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
13,343
36,483
1,054
Can you share a screenshot please of them saying it belonged to Lynette's parents? I don't remember it being anything other than an allusion.
After you have sex with Jill, the game shows Jill's photo fade into Lynette's. It's never stated in dialogue because no one is currently aware of the connection, but if that's not a confirmation then idk what is.
ep8_jill_lewd144.png ep8_jill_lewd145.png
ezgif.com-resize.gif
 

dontehall2023

Member
Dec 16, 2023
259
288
196
It has much credibility as the Riona is dead argument.
The Riona is dead theory I think is just a dig at her fans. She's not dead. There's zero chance they're throwing a Christmas party if Riona is dead. Not caring about Mona leaving? Maybe. She was a freshman & plenty of people find college to not be their thing after experiencing it. Riona disappearing & all of the HOTs not working to find her? Not happening. I can't see Sage being okay with "note" saying I'm leaving school forever.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Burn85

dontehall2023

Member
Dec 16, 2023
259
288
196

dontehall2023

Member
Dec 16, 2023
259
288
196
If you dismiss the visual storytelling, then yes, we have no confirmation.
But there's two other girls there. The only thing that those pictures are telling me is that Lynette was tied to Jill's current house in some way. Whether it was the house of a friend or her parent's house. The answer has yet to be revealed. I'd say it's a strong assumption that it was MC grandparent's house.
 
4.70 star(s) 1,732 Votes