I quite disagree -- i have actually loved how unapologetically selfish and all-in DIK Zoey was there, willing to put very much everything on the line. You don't really make this sort of request if you don't care about someone to the point of wanting them above all else.But DIK Zoey just killed the vibe of the moment. I know her personality is being more sassy, aggressive, and straightforward. I always liked the DIK version of her for her brashness: returning the favor to Emma, kicking a firefighter for harassing her on the dance floor, more uninhibited dialogue. Kiled her lines. I like how she snapped at Becky while Chick Zoey ignored it. She's more fun. But at the same time, DIK Zoey is more selfish, as the love declare scene showed. I could overlook one kiss, I'm not a saint myself on some routes (Bianca), but this line:
View attachment 4649560
JUST NO. By reacting this way when you tell her that “I’m already in a relationship,” Zoey makes it clear that she doesn’t care about your feelings. She’s thinking about herself. This is a red flag and immediately pushed me away. That's like ultra level of being selfish. “I don’t want you to be with me if you don’t sure” slightly improves the situation, but still leaves an unpleasant aftertaste.
But i also have a slightly different interpretation of this scene -- when Zoey says she doesn't care, i think she's responding more to what Fuckface leaves unsaid when he brings up he's in relationship. Which is, if he was to choose Zoey, then his current girlfriend would be disappointed and hurt. And i think that's more what Zoey refers to when she says she doesn't care. She puts her feelings over feelings of the other girl (and honestly, why shouldn't she) not the MC, but she is also giving Fuckface a convenient way to reduce his guilt, by "merely" accepting Zoey's request, instead of making the decision all on his own and completely unprompted. In this sense, i'm actually less impressed with Chick Zoey who basically leaves the ball completely in Fuckface's court. Even though she knows that he's a hysterical snowflake who's gonna huff and puff and triple-guess himself while moping for next two weeks.