Rehwyn

Engaged Member
Apr 10, 2024
2,421
4,478
349
I wonder if Chad will have made the connection with when Sage gave him the chance to be honest one last time, but he still didn't.
Might take some time, but it wouldn't surprise me if he eventually reframes that conversation with the understanding she already knew.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chillout1984

cooldevo

Active Member
Jan 30, 2021
895
1,068
211
Do Jill and Bella serve as legal advisors? In the end they just repeat what they had said before
Jill offered the use of her family lawyer, I think she'd be smart enough to NOT offer legal advice... as that in and of itself can become a legal issue.

The timelines are often a bit quirky in the game. Sometimes between scenes it's concurrent with the previous one and other times it appears days have passed between what we actually see. I try to use the parties they plan as a rough timeline give or take a few days here and there.
 

Geralt From Rivia

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 15, 2022
7,851
50,670
812
Agreed that the decision to share that info is probably better left to Sage, but once the decision to share it with Josy was made I think it's better to be honest about her knowing. It'll probably come out sooner or later, and the longer it's been, the more it'll probably hurt.

Edit: It's been a while since I played Episode 8, but wasn't the decision to tell Josy partially to get advice on if MC should tell Sage about Chad? That makes it more excusable in my book.
The decision to tell Josy in Ep.8 only affects Sage presence on Patrick heist, which reduces his suspicion by -1. So it's the right decision, which gives MC a better chance of stealing the papers. You can choose whether to tell Sage about Chad and Troy or not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rehwyn

Chillout1984

Forum Fanatic
Nov 15, 2020
5,991
4,352
333
I do wonder why out of nowhere (to me at least) she seems to have fallen for him starting with season 3 (although we already know of her "competition" with Sarah since at least the dorm party).

Except for their sex scenes they don't seem to have much contact with each other. At least Camila still joins him and his group often and also shares a class. Even during parties their chats seem to be minimum.
 

El_Magnifico

Engaged Member
Sep 26, 2023
2,106
10,413
646
Her recent questioning and evolution (fashion, social networks) seems to come out of nowhere and is very artificial (and makes Josy appear even more superficial, which doesn't help her).
It's hard to see any potential with her path. Her becoming an influencer and gaining consequent sponsorship could have solved Maya's money situation but like you said her student loan arc is already finished. She only stands out with negative traits. Her insecurities, her jealousy, her obsession. Maybe DPC thought that giving her a new hobby would make her less dull and more confident but what she really needed was a real arc.
 

Igetby

Member
Jun 15, 2020
216
173
111
Only Derek knows about the physical abuse but as of the library planning meeting, Sage, Jill and Bella all know that Patrick is threatening Maya's education funding because she's dating Josy. True, we don't know how much Maya shared but they (especially Jill) could have interpreted what's going on as a form of psychological abuse or "bullying." Yes, Maya's tuition plot is extremely forced overall and glad that's over. All things considered, outside of certain paths, the MG group just doesn't seem that forced imo. DPC could have given no signs whatsoever that they were all interacting and then it would have really seemed forced.

Yeah, on the college blackmail storyline issue. I finished that part last night and I kept thinking "just get a student loan" glad that is over with.
 

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
13,336
36,478
1,054
I do wonder why out of nowhere (to me at least) she seems to have fallen for him starting with season 3 (although we already know of her "competition" with Sarah since at least the dorm party).

Except for their sex scenes they don't seem to have much contact with each other. At least Camila still joins him and his group often and also shares a class. Even during parties their chats seem to be minimum.
Cammy is also a freshman, that makes constant interaction easier with MC.

Between her and Sarah, Mel's always been the sweeter of the two. While the more romantic-ish moments happen in Season 3, she's definitely much more physically interested in MC than Sarah in the first two seasons.
 

Rehwyn

Engaged Member
Apr 10, 2024
2,421
4,478
349
The decision to tell Josy in Ep.8 only affects Sage presence on Patrick heist, which reduces his suspicion by -1. So it's the right decision, which gives MC a better chance of stealing the papers. You can choose whether to tell Sage about Chad and Troy or not.
Right, I remember it affects her presence at Patrick's. But I was trying to remember why MC told Josy in the first place. If I remember right, it's because he wasn't certain whether to tell Sage or not. On the one hand, Sage deserved to know but on the other hand it was going to hurt her. If I remember right, that's why he considered telling Josy to get her advice.
 

treechild1

Engaged Member
Nov 16, 2024
2,005
3,203
341
did Quinn and Ryona really deserve all that? seems over the top ngl
Nobody “deserves” anything like that. Thankfully, this is fiction. You can’t have a (decent) story without conflict. Apparently, we also need deep drama in our porn novels. For variety’s sake. Also, many people find pure happy paragon stories lame and boring. So, there you go. DPC (and Jillybean) warned us, we should take them at their word. This ride isn’t going to be for everyone. I agree, however, that getting us to care for characters and then having us watch them suffer, sucks…
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chillout1984

dontehall2023

Member
Dec 16, 2023
259
288
196
How many relationship paths do you think are going to ultimately exist in this game?

I count;

Bella
Bianca
Camila
Cinderella
Jade
Jill
Josy
Lily
Maya
Melanie
Nicole
Nora
Quinn
Riona
Sage
Sally
Zoey
 

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
13,336
36,478
1,054
How many relationship paths do you think are going to ultimately exist in this game?

I count;

Bella
Bianca
Camila
Cinderella
Jade
Jill
Josy
Lily
Maya
Melanie
Nicole
Nora
Quinn
Riona
Sage
Sally
Zoey
Cathy and Sarah. Also, if we're calling relationships "an on going thing" at minimum, Tara might become another fuckbuddy.
 

Geralt From Rivia

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 15, 2022
7,851
50,670
812
Right, I remember it affects her presence at Patrick's. But I was trying to remember why MC told Josy in the first place. If I remember right, it's because he wasn't certain whether to tell Sage or not. On the one hand, Sage deserved to know but on the other hand it was going to hurt her. If I remember right, that's why he considered telling Josy to get her advice.
He was shocked by what he saw and detached from reality during training, which Josy noticed and began to ask what was going on, then we have a choice to tell her or not. Josy didn't give a clear answer whether to tell Sage, she said that she wouldn't want to be in his situation at all.
 

felicemastronzo

Message Maven
May 17, 2020
12,243
23,233
978
Jill offered the use of her family lawyer, I think she'd be smart enough to NOT offer legal advice... as that in and of itself can become a legal issue.

The timelines are often a bit quirky in the game. Sometimes between scenes it's concurrent with the previous one and other times it appears days have passed between what we actually see. I try to use the parties they plan as a rough timeline give or take a few days here and there.
Jill offers the family lawyer's help during the Halloween party. But for now it is actually she and Bella who advise Maya from that point of view. Now in theory the lawyer is needed for the contract Maya signed with her father for the return of money spent on college. But considering that there has been a reconciliation with patrick I would say that it is no longer needed, except if it is important to find out who this lawyer is.

The problem with the whole loan storyline is that it was supposed to end with the reacquaintance with Patrick', everything in between was a boring waste of time and was counterproductive for the characters, Maya first but not only her
 

ModiThorrson

Active Member
Jan 1, 2024
657
1,199
253
Nobody “deserves” anything like that. Thankfully, this is fiction. You can’t have a (decent) story without conflict. Apparently, we also need deep drama in our porn novels.
If all I wanted was a bunch of sex scenes, I'd just go to pornhub. Personally the AVN genre is of interest because mainstream media is censored, mainstream media has only recently leaned into sex amongst the drama with tshows like GoT, Shameless, etc. I get that some content shouldn't be exposed to younger people before a certain age, but that doesn't mean people should be ashamed of having a healthy interest in adult topics. So it's nice being able to read these stories, and not censor out the questionable content.
 

NebulousShooter

Forum Fanatic
Donor
Oct 24, 2018
4,676
32,019
647
Right, I remember it affects her presence at Patrick's. But I was trying to remember why MC told Josy in the first place. If I remember right, it's because he wasn't certain whether to tell Sage or not. On the one hand, Sage deserved to know but on the other hand it was going to hurt her. If I remember right, that's why he considered telling Josy to get her advice.
The why is because Josy can probably understand why would Chad do something like that, seeing that she in a same sex relationship and hiding it.(and potentially cheated as well) :cautious:
But considering that there has been a reconciliation with patrick I would say that it is no longer needed, except if it is important to find out who this lawyer is.
Priscila? :eek:
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: felicemastronzo
4.70 star(s) 1,732 Votes