Its great if you just wanna get laid but if the MC actually cared about these girls it’s a clusterfuck.
Both of them can’t be trusted. If the MC were to actually fall in love with Maya/Josy and try for a three way relationship he’d have to accept they lied repeatedly to each other, and him, for personal gain. Plus if someone cheats with you, chances are they’ll cheat on you.
The situation is great if you just want sex but an actual non-porn plot relationship with them is fundamentally tainted. Theyre liars. They continued to be liars right up until the MC told the truth. For all of Ep4 Maya and Josy were together and neither deigned to tell the other about why the MC was upset.