Holy Bacchus

Conversation Conqueror
Dec 13, 2018
7,748
19,552
789
Yeah I know Bacchus, I understand that this has been stated, and apparently "proven" to be false. Thing is, it could all be just a ruse. Would it be shocking? Yes. Would it turn people off? Some for sure, but no more than the brutality of AL. I think if done correctly it would make for a good story arc.
When the dev says it's not going to happen, then I think that pretty much proves it. It's not going to be a cheap "ruse", especially when there's another named rich family he could be related that can still cause drama but doesn't fuck up a relationship with a LI.

That said, Jill has "something" in her background that is dark.. maybe not AL dark, but certainly not happy. Why such empathy over bullying? I just can't shake the feeling that it will be something at least as surprising as her being related. But I know that this is a dead horse. I just am trying to connect some dots on why the MC will choose anyone else other than Jill, as she is definitely being offered as the path of least resistance.
I've often thought that perhaps her sister may have committed suicide as a result of bullying and that's why Jill is an anti-bullying advocate.
 

MrFriendly

Officially Dead Inside
Donor
Feb 23, 2020
5,877
14,493
859
Me too. Epsiode 5 was probably my least favorite. 1-3 were so good and 4 had it's moments.
Yeah, Episode 5 was too Maya and Josey focused for me... The overall story didn't feel like it progressed.
 

ename144

Engaged Member
Sep 20, 2018
3,741
15,528
681
First of all, no, but secondly, DPC has explicitly stated that there will be no incest as they don't like it, so the MC will not be related to Jill.

I really don't know how many times we have to go through this. :FacePalm:
You know, I think we're missing the real story here.

We all know people will never stop proposing "it isn't technically incest since the MC hasn't had sex with Jill yet" theories. Clearly, the only way to end the madness once and for all is for the MC to have sex with Jill.

Thus we, the audience, are ourselves motivated for this outcome just as the young, horny MC is. It drives home the same uncontrollable eagerness and anxiety our avatar is feeling as he pursues his dream girl. When you think about it, it's a stroke of meta-brilliance.

That, or the internet is a cesspool of crazy fetishes that will never die. But that would just be too depressing if it were true. :whistle:


That's far more likely and more interesting. Just imagine Rusty being all, "hey, I've got a cousin!", and becoming really pally with the MC. It would piss Tommy off so much and really further his downward spiral.
In all seriousness, how would this be any different than Rusty becoming pals with the MC because he likes and respects him? That's already well on the way to happening without and Burgmeister blood, so it seems like much ado about nothing.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: --5555

MrFriendly

Officially Dead Inside
Donor
Feb 23, 2020
5,877
14,493
859
You know, I think we're missing the real story here.

We all know people will never stop proposing "it isn't technically incest since the MC hasn't had sex with Jill yet" theories. Clearly, the only way to end the madness once and for all is for the MC to have sex with Jill.

Thus we, the audience, are ourselves motivated for this outcome just as the young, horny MC is. It drives home the same uncontrollable eagerness and anxiety our avatar is feeling as he pursues his dream girl. When you think about it, it's a stroke of meta-brilliance.

That, or the internet is a cesspool of crazy fetishes that will never die. But that would just be too depressing if it were true. :whistle:



In all seriousness, how would this be any different than Rusty becoming pals with the MC because he likes and respects him? That's already well on the way to happening without and Burgmeister blood, so it seems like much ado about nothing.
Well, it doesn't necessarily except for solving the mystery of what the letter says... Which is most of the reason I suggested it.
 

ename144

Engaged Member
Sep 20, 2018
3,741
15,528
681
Yeah, Episode 5 was too Maya and Josey focused for me... The overall story didn't feel like it progressed.
That's because the story didn't progress. It was specifically structured to avoid advancing any of the actual plotlines. It even went out of its way to keep the romances in limbo. The episode is just a bunch of nice-but-light-weight character snippets that stitch together a slew of gratuitous sex scenes.

I'm not sure what that has to do with Maya or Josy, though. They have a relatively small roll in the events (especially if you aren't on their path), and the excuse to not advance their romance is the weakest of them all.
 

lemonfreak

The Freakiest of Lemons
Oct 24, 2018
5,611
10,421
925
He could be removed as DIK presidant after the meeting with the counselors, we'll have to wait and see how that goes, so that's how he could be "gone" right now. But I do believe he's in his final year which means he'd be graduating, so if he doesn't get removed, the MC could become DIK president after that.
Rusty and Tommy are both third years so no, they're not graduating this year, unless they've been particularly dedicated to their studies which seems unlikely given their characterisation thus far.
 

Kellermann

Engaged Member
Oct 20, 2020
3,622
11,825
678
I've often thought that perhaps her sister may have committed suicide as a result of bullying and that's why Jill is an anti-bullying advocate.
Exactly. It has to be something incredibly emotional to make anti-bullying so deadly serious to Jill. Your theory about her sister makes the most sense to me. It can't just be, oh I saw the fat kid getting picked on in 6th grade and now I'm a crusader in the fight against bullying. Also, since Jill is rich and beautiful, I doubt she experienced much if any direct bullying herself, so that's crossed off the list of reasons too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrFriendly

Rule97

Member
May 2, 2018
436
237
159
I asked Josy and Maya for something more, thry said they weren't ready, is that because i didn't score enough points? Or is it part of their path?
 
Mar 18, 2019
245
150
97
I asked Josy and Maya for something more, thry said they weren't ready, is that because i didn't score enough points? Or is it part of their path?
If you were to download the gallery mod, you’ll be able to easily change to Chick or DIK and change M&J relationship level. I’m not saying do it but it’s easier than going back and forth trying to get full Chick or full DIK
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rule97

felicemastronzo

Message Maven
May 17, 2020
12,218
23,209
978
You know, I think we're missing the real story here.

We all know people will never stop proposing "it isn't technically incest since the MC hasn't had sex with Jill yet" theories. Clearly, the only way to end the madness once and for all is for the MC to have sex with Jill.

Thus we, the audience, are ourselves motivated for this outcome just as the young, horny MC is. It drives home the same uncontrollable eagerness and anxiety our avatar is feeling as he pursues his dream girl. When you think about it, it's a stroke of meta-brilliance.

That, or the internet is a cesspool of crazy fetishes that will never die. But that would just be too depressing if it were true. :whistle:



In all seriousness, how would this be any different than Rusty becoming pals with the MC because he likes and respects him? That's already well on the way to happening without and Burgmeister blood, so it seems like much ado about nothing.
I wonder if Jill's situation is wanted by DPC or not.

I think he is aware of the reactions of the players, so maybe he plays with it, like with Bella's secret room, which becomes a source of infinite theory, when realistically it should have a rather trivial motivation
 

$JACKIE1492

Member
Sep 19, 2018
164
408
248
OI mates I know this isn't the Acting Lessons thread but I had to make a tribute to Melissa. I played this game a while back and still to this day my heart is still broken. I loved all the characters but Melissa was the one i had a strong connection to. I put it on here cause there is more traffic here and I was curious about feed back.
Here's the link hope you lads like it cheers!!!
 
Mar 18, 2019
245
150
97
Probably gonna get banned of this thread, but imo Camilla, Sarah, and Melanie/Mel are the hottest HOTs (beside Sage because she’s like a main character)
 

Vollezar

Gingers are love. Gingers are life.
Game Developer
Aug 14, 2020
1,572
9,309
688
OI mates I know this isn't the Acting Lessons thread but I had to make a tribute to Melissa. I played this game a while back and still to this day my heart is still broken. I loved all the characters but Melissa was the one i had a strong connection to. I put it on here cause there is more traffic here and I was curious about feed back.
Here's the link hope you lads like it cheers!!!
I miss her. I wish she would have a cameo here.
 
4.70 star(s) 1,728 Votes