Recommending Butter's Ultimate(?) Wholesome Games/Doujins List! (a la VoltageFlame) || Also a Discussion and Recommendations Thread! (UPD: 12/17/24!!)

[butter_scotch13]

i was on edge because i saw the rape tag but there legitimately isnt any in the entire game (afaik)
mistag(?)

 

[butter_scotch13]

its... so peak
i think i need ANOTHER tier similar to 1Room

(should i add a god tier? these two games are legitimately the most wholesome ive ever played, this one might be even MORE wholesome than even 1Room)

 

[Arabi1]

its... so peak
i think i need ANOTHER tier similar to 1Room

(should i add a god tier? these two games are legitimately the most wholesome ive ever played, this one might be even MORE wholesome than even 1Room)

I have played 1room and a little bit of JSK games and I have kept myself quiet about it... but man are you serious? There are way more wholesome games I played than these. The problem is that it has tags you don't like, like harem. If you don't believe me, try these:

https://f95zone.to/threads/lets-go-my-harem-farm-v1-1-0-xo_project.176031/
https://f95zone.to/threads/tratritle-v1-3-5-inazuma-soft.124085/

And if you really don't like harem games, try this one:

https://f95zone.to/threads/mechanica-a-ballad-of-the-rabbit-and-mercury-final-loser-s.94550/

Pretty wholesome relationship with the robot.

 

[butter_scotch13]

I have played 1room and a little bit of JSK games and I have kept myself quiet about it... but man are you serious? There are way more wholesome games I played than these. The problem is that it has tags you don't like, like harem. If you don't believe me, try these:

https://f95zone.to/threads/lets-go-my-harem-farm-v1-1-0-xo_project.176031/
https://f95zone.to/threads/tratritle-v1-3-5-inazuma-soft.124085/

And if you really don't like harem games, try this one:

https://f95zone.to/threads/mechanica-a-ballad-of-the-rabbit-and-mercury-final-loser-s.94550/

Pretty wholesome relationship with the robot.

I was talking about bottle biosphere

 

[Arabi1]

I was talking about bottle biosphere

Ohh I didn't see that before, but since it has pregnancy tag it's already 10/10.

Edit: butter_scotch13 Also can you confirm that it has visible virginity loss? I'm looking for such contnet here and I'm wondering about this game since it has virgin tag.

 

[Mario4don]

Nice list, although it's a bit of a shame that you don't like incest because I have no objections to the rest of what you don't like because I personally don't like the other kinks you mentioned in the OP too.

But ... personally I think that you could have included links to this games on your list in the OP, because it's a bit awkward to navigate in the OP if you only have game titles and not links to them on f95 and then you have to search for them yourself on the forum, and it's very easy to link the title of each game to a given game on this forum right away.

 

[nnt1996]

I have played 1room and a little bit of JSK games and I have kept myself quiet about it... but man are you serious? There are way more wholesome games I played than these. The problem is that it has tags you don't like, like harem. If you don't believe me, try these:

https://f95zone.to/threads/lets-go-my-harem-farm-v1-1-0-xo_project.176031/
https://f95zone.to/threads/tratritle-v1-3-5-inazuma-soft.124085/

And if you really don't like harem games, try this one:

https://f95zone.to/threads/mechanica-a-ballad-of-the-rabbit-and-mercury-final-loser-s.94550/

Pretty wholesome relationship with the robot.

First of, rude
Second, doesn’t look better to me, especially with those artstyles, looks really lust focused instead of love, even if its not, the artstyles still did not look better imo, the girls look too skinny, tiny and all of them look like a teen

The only one of these that i like the artstyle is the harem farm one, which is a shame since i mostly dislike harem and polygamy…and is that a screen shot of a girl graphically giving birth? Wtf?

And those games probably force you and don’t give you the freedom of choices like JSK does

In conclusion,man are you serious Joshua Weissman?

visible virginity loss

All JSK games have that

 

[Arabi1]

First of, rude
Second, doesn’t look better to me, especially with those artstyles, looks really lust focused instead of love, even if its not, the artstyles still did not look better imo, the girls look too skinny, tiny and all of them look like a teen

The only one of these that i like the artstyle is the harem farm one, which is a shame since i mostly dislike harem and polygamy…and is that a screen shot of a girl graphically giving birth? Wtf?

And those games probably force you and don’t give you the freedom of choices like JSK does

In conclusion,man are you serious Joshua Weissman?

All JSK games have that

Yes, you're right and I know, so I kept quiet at first. Yes, there are skinny women, there are bbw, milf and teenagers, I suggested harem, so this is not an issue, the menu is full, all body types are available and all of them are welcome to me, other than that their personalities are distinct from each others, what matters is the soul, not the body.

I know you're trying to be rude back, and that's your right, but to pretend to describe procreation as if it was gore is ridiculous.

Still, I'm grateful to you for answering me.

 

[butter_scotch13]

Nice list, although it's a bit of a shame that you don't like incest because I have no objections to the rest of what you don't like because I personally don't like the other kinks you mentioned in the OP too.

But ... personally I think that you could have included links to this games on your list in the OP, because it's a bit awkward to navigate in the OP if you only have game titles and not links to them on f95 and then you have to search for them yourself on the forum, and it's very easy to link the title of each game to a given game on this forum right away.

I’ve never used f95 besides this post (excluding me asking for headpat games, those are reactionary from when I watch too many cat videos) so I didn’t actually know you could link that easily, I’ll do that in a bit, thanks!

Also, I have siblings so 100% no incest for me, ever..

 

[butter_scotch13]

Ohh I didn't see that before, but since it has pregnancy tag it's already 10/10.

Edit: butter_scotch13 Also can you confirm that it has visible virginity loss? I'm looking for such contnet here and I'm wondering about this game since it has virgin tag.

I don't think it's visible, but it does say '...mixture of blood and love juice...' during her first time

Also i updated the list (finally!)

 

[butter_scotch13]

Ohh I didn't see that before, but since it has pregnancy tag it's already 10/10.

Edit: butter_scotch13 Also can you confirm that it has visible virginity loss? I'm looking for such contnet here and I'm wondering about this game since it has virgin tag.

Every game on here has some sort of defloration (since it's vanilla, the mc is the only love interest and therefore all of them are also virgins), but it usually isn't stressed or detailed much besides the slight mention of blood or a little pain

 

[nnt1996]

Yes, you're right and I know, so I kept quiet at first. Yes, there are skinny women, there are bbw, milf and teenagers, I suggested harem, so this is not an issue, the menu is full, all body types are available and all of them are welcome to me, other than that their personalities are distinct from each others, what matters is the soul, not the body.

I know you're trying to be rude back, and that's your right, but to pretend to describe procreation as if it was gore is ridiculous.

Still, I'm grateful to you for answering me.

Its hard NOT to be rude to you especially after that “Man can’t be rape” comment of yours, Joshua Weissman

Just sayin

 

[butter_scotch13]

A lot of the people in the S:C discord convinced me to try out ravager- I’m really put off by the amount of rape/dubious consent in it, but from what I’ve heard it’s a really fun game with a good bit of romance and just enough options to avoid the worst scenes

 

[Arabi1]

A lot of the people in the S:C discord convinced me to try out ravager- I’m really put off by the amount of rape/dubious consent in it, but from what I’ve heard it’s a really fun game with a good bit of romance and just enough options to avoid the worst scenes

I don't know what S:C stands for. I have played and finished Ravager. The game is not fun. At first I was impressed by the voice acting (which later disappeared), but from the middle to the end of the game it was pretty boring with only a few events that caught my attention. You just click some choices while exploring hoping that something happens. 3 stars, an average game.

And yes, rape is the main focus of the game, you either rape the women or take them and let your goblins rape them. And if you refuse to rape you will be locked out of that content. Not wholesome at all, maybe with a character or two after you rape them and put them in jail, but the general atmosphere of the game is not for that for as much as I experience it.

 

[Skandranon]

I don't know what S:C stands for. I have played and finished Ravager. The game is not fun. At first I was impressed by the voice acting (which later disappeared), but from the middle to the end of the game it was pretty boring with only a few events that caught my attention. You just click some choices while exploring hoping that something happens. 3 stars, an average game.

And yes, rape is the main focus of the game, you either rape the women or take them and let your goblins rape them. And if you refuse to rape you will be locked out of that content. Not wholesome at all, maybe with a character or two after you rape them and put them in jail, but the general atmosphere of the game is not for that for as much as I experience it.

Eh...that's not really true. All except I think...two women have more-or-less consensual routes, and the consensual routes have far more content.

 

[Arabi1]

Eh...that's not really true. All except I think...two women have more-or-less consensual routes, and the consensual routes have far more content.

It's been a year but I'm I remember the MC's teenage daughter forcing him to have sex with her late in the game, and that's not a big deal to me, but incest is not vanilla. And Tbf I don't remember if she was a teenager or an adult because the plot of her going from baby to consenting age in one day was a bit confusing.

 

[Skandranon]

It's been a year but I'm I remember the MC's teenage daughter forcing him to have sex with her late in the game, and that's not a big deal to me, but incest is not vanilla. And Tbf I don't remember if she was a teenager or an adult because the plot of her going from baby to consenting age in one day was a bit confusing.

Oh I didn't say it was vanilla, it's already a dragon having sex ofc.

But there's far more content and you can completely avoid rape. Even that scene you just named can be consensual.

I'm just disputing the idea that rape is the focus; most of the girls if you rape them their plotlines stop going anywhere.

 

[Oh-Taco]

ok uh
originally I planned on playing through Konko and a lot of the other games Oh-Taco recommended me
but..
i appear to have to actually study and do stuff with my life (college? what’s that?) so my time is probably better spent on some other stuff

I’ll try to update this list because it’s something I like doing (helping people find wholesome content is my passion!) but definitely not too frequently anymore

if anyone hasn’t seen this list yet, you’re welcome and also check out what Oh-Taco recommended! Highly suggest all of them : D

Hi, I'm a bit late in my reply as I have been out of the house for the last week.

I just wanted to wish you luck with everything coming up, whether it be life, studies, work (actual responsibility? No way), or whatever else you find yourself in and I'm glad to hear you liked my initial recommendations as I did spend quite a few hours digging and adding them.

Now with that out of the way, I'd also like to add that I will try to keep recommending more games if and when I can. But as with you, life comes first, and finding my way out of this mire I've been stuck in for a while seems like a good start.

I kind of strayed off-topic regarding the actual purpose of this thread AND spent way too much time formulating/revising this, though I don’t mind—it’s been quite fun in its own right. I just wanted to give my piece.

Sadly, I have no recommendations to offer at the moment, but you'll be seeing more of me—I’m not gone yet!

 

[ohnonottome]

Oh yeah, I've seen happiness double room but i absolutely hate ntr. I'm not touching a game if it has it ANYWHERE

I just wanted to say I think you should reconsider this point. Double Room's NTR is a 100% optional route you pick near the start and is disabled by default. It's also not precisely NTR as the LI in her heart is still loyal to the MC (she's just selling her body for info), although it does provoke an NTR panic attack from the MC. Honestly it's less of an "NTR" route and more of a "misery ending" where both parties wind up extremely unhappy.

But the rest of the game is very good. Lots of affirmation, doting, flirting, and passionate consensual sex. There aren't a lot of headpats as the game focuses on the LI doting on the MC instead, but it's ultimately about both people learning that love means helping each other out. There's kind of a dark reason as to why the heroine keeps the MC imprisoned, but the game handles it in a surprisingly adult way in the true ending that is both sad and hopeful. Definitely a darkly wholesome game that I still remember very fondly, and deserves more love even from people that LOATHE NTR.

 

[Bife Grelhado]

the way you write made me smile, so good thread (like emoji)