When I go too far into an idea and start adding useless details, I end up with something like this. I made a spreadsheet that I'm in the process of filling in (will take a long time!) and naming the tiers I've separated the girls into is incomplete, but I've added the 12 from here, since it's where this started (no Kaili or Anne... yet?) I may tweak these a bit as I go, because I tend to get a better feel for the rankings the more I add to the list.
A couple of pointers - Tier 2 is basically the best most will achieve, but Tier 1 is those who would be in that category but just have a little something extra, putting them ahead of even the best. Tier 5 is for "Hot... but" - there's just something that doesn't work for me, otherwise she would be higher.
And yeah, I plan to do this for all my games eventually, as it will also act as a visual guide making it easier for me to remember names and faces!
I struggled to find a good Tara picture to use (if anyone has a good one, I just want a proper face showing) and the same for Linda (the "present day" look also just makes me think of Elena from BaD!)
View attachment 3827811