WICKEDp4th

Before Alice went to Wonderland, she had to fall.
Donor
Sep 6, 2017
3,356
5,696
Man, I must be working with half a deck here. I do not understand how putting Lisa and Tara in a new visual novel could possibly be high risk. They are just characters in a visual novel. Like actors, they play different parts in different stories. And that any person could possibly be upset that a character in a visual novel is not a virgin is disturbing. People love the Lisa and Tara characters. It makes sense to put them in a new story. Even if the devs changed their names for a new story, they are just characters!
People will argue that they cheat on the MC of Chasing Sunsets...guaranteed.
I once had this conversation on a another VN with a fellow member.
 

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,336
22,055
they may be naïve, stupid, insecure, and retarded. but at the end of the merry-go-round it is we who play their games and not the other way around, so it is they who are being proved right. :cautious:

because if it is ridiculous to pretend that LI is a virgin and only interested in MC, how ridiculous is Jaye that for 5 years, but it could have been more, she waits for the man (by the way her foster brother) with whom she has never had any relationship but only a crush really, and who once back could also safely dump her???
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: WICKEDp4th

Ilhares

Engaged Member
Aug 19, 2019
2,925
11,212
because if it is ridiculous to pretend that LI is a virgin and only interested in MC, how ridiculous is Jaye that for 5 years, but it could have been more, she waits for the man (by the way her foster brother) with whom she has never had any relationship but only a crush really, and who once back could also safely dump her???
She's only a virgin, I thought, if you were extremely dedicated/kind to her in the game. Did that get rewritten and I missed something?
 

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,336
22,055
She's only a virgin, I thought, if you were extremely dedicated/kind to her in the game. Did that get rewritten and I missed something?
extremely dedicated seems to me a stretch, as it's not like you have other girls available. if you are "nice" to her (it's a couple of decisions), the game rewards you with her virginity. virginity is Jaye's "perfect ending"

If you are not enough nice the game punishes you with a more normal Jaye
 
  • Like
Reactions: ename144

Hellkinglucifer

Active Member
Apr 29, 2020
794
1,890
Ah the classic “wants their cake and wants to eat it too” being thrown by stone fox here though I don't see the tara game doing aswell as they think. Didn't want to make Tara a main Li because that would mean changing the story in a way they don't want to which is fine(even if i didn't like it)as ultimately it is the dev decision. There are examples on this site of games where dev changed stories to pander to the audience which ended up abandoned as the dev lost interest in making a game that wasn't what they wanted anymore.

But if the whole in an alternate reality thing is real then it is a rather cheap attempt of erasing Tara backstory which is a rather important reason why people like her while still trying to catch the Tara lightning in a bottle popularity. Reasons to do that are probably to clear the relationship between Tara and the MC so playing the 2nd game MC don't feel like the 2nd choice, rebound guy. Won't even delve into the virgin thing, 3 words of mass destruction, sloppy seconds or cheating on previous mc. But at this point it's not even Tara anymore so why just keep the same model, create a new character and start fresh. Dev really dug itself into a hole with this thing with MC, Jaye and Tara acting as a conduit between them. Game would have progressed fine without the MC/Tara and Tara/Jaye sex scenes and the hints of her liking mc.

Imagine this Chasing sunsets starts us playing douchebag and vividly describe how douchebag and Jaye met, liked each other, fucked then douchebag left her for Tara. Prologue ends, real story starts with us playing MC now. Epic game right, guaranteed to succeed :ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO:
 

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,336
22,055
What for?
The players diving to deep into the self insertion of a MC of a Visual Novel and calling pixels cheating whores because they appear in other VN's?
it's not that it's very complicated....

they want their LI to be virgin and dedicated only to MC, and in this game, but the many AVNs, that's what they get
 

WICKEDp4th

Before Alice went to Wonderland, she had to fall.
Donor
Sep 6, 2017
3,356
5,696
it's not that it's very complicated....

they want their LI to be virgin and dedicated only to MC, and in this game, but the many AVNs, that's what they get
That's okay for the actual VN/Game, but imho that ends at the Quit-Button. Next Game/VN is a new story to be written/enjoyed.
 

WICKEDp4th

Before Alice went to Wonderland, she had to fall.
Donor
Sep 6, 2017
3,356
5,696
Ah, Tara. She kinda loses her appeal when she isn't pretending to be your sister to get you hard, doesn't she? Without that one trick she is basically just Chloe from College Kings.
She hasn't much screentime after that hail mary scene, so scarcity leads to oblivion i guess.
 

PaxHadrian17

Engaged Member
Sep 8, 2020
2,001
9,717
True, people complained about Jaye's lack of virginity, but so far the devs have stuck to their guns about it. IMHO, that's they should; I find the obsession with LIs being virgins borderline creepy. Other people are free to disagree, of course, but that may ultimately mean the game isn't for them. You can't please everyone all the time, and trying to do so is a slippery slope to mediocrity.
I understand that people like to have a variety of playthroughs.

On my first playthrough of CS - I built full trust and love with Jaye early on - and she was a virgin who waited for the MC for their first time.

I also played later with a different focus for the MC/Jaye, breaking trust with Jaye - I was not shocked At all when she was not a virgin when she and the MC had their first time.

I like a story where there is consequence for the actions of the MC.

I don't understand those who complained that Jaye was not a virgin the first time she and the MC had sex when their choices did not create the bond of trust that Jaye needed to remain faithful to a hope (one she still held).

If this is what some people required of Jaye - her virginity for the MC - create a new playthrough - isn't that what replayability is all about?

Does the story still streamline (no ability to expand the primary LI roster beyond Jaye/Mallory) so we end up with less 'choice' than some of us want - sure.

I'll take that over a 1 year = 1 release dev cycle though.

Cheers!! :coffee:
 

Nurikabe

Well-Known Member
Feb 10, 2021
1,328
2,874
Ah the classic “wants their cake and wants to eat it too” being thrown by stone fox here though I don't see the tara game doing aswell as they think. Didn't want to make Tara a main Li because that would mean changing the story in a way they don't want to which is fine(even if i didn't like it)as ultimately it is the dev decision. There are examples on this site of games where dev changed stories to pander to the audience which ended up abandoned as the dev lost interest in making a game that wasn't what they wanted anymore.

But if the whole in an alternate reality thing is real then it is a rather cheap attempt of erasing Tara backstory which is a rather important reason why people like her while still trying to catch the Tara lightning in a bottle popularity. Reasons to do that are probably to clear the relationship between Tara and the MC so playing the 2nd game MC don't feel like the 2nd choice, rebound guy. Won't even delve into the virgin thing, 3 words of mass destruction, sloppy seconds or cheating on previous mc. But at this point it's not even Tara anymore so why just keep the same model, create a new character and start fresh. Dev really dug itself into a hole with this thing with MC, Jaye and Tara acting as a conduit between them. Game would have progressed fine without the MC/Tara and Tara/Jaye sex scenes and the hints of her liking mc.

Imagine this Chasing sunsets starts us playing douchebag and vividly describe how douchebag and Jaye met, liked each other, fucked then douchebag left her for Tara. Prologue ends, real story starts with us playing MC now. Epic game right, guaranteed to succeed :ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO:
Nobody has seen the new game yet. Tools passing judgment on something that doesn't even exist yet. There is no reason or need to speculate what Tara or Lisa will be like in the next game. We don't have any clue what the story is. No clue what will be pulled in from this story.

As far as using the Tara or Lisa model in a new VN, both of those characters are very popular in Chasing Sunsets. You could put them in any story and people would want to see that. There are models that get used over and over by devs. They use models that serve their purpose and have staying power, like any actor in a movie. On top of that, Kentrr put a lot of work into those models. It is awesome, beautiful work. I can't wait to see those characters in another story.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: WICKEDp4th
Oct 10, 2022
4,349
7,735
People will argue that they cheat on the MC of Chasing Sunsets...guaranteed.
I once had this conversation on a another VN with a fellow member.
I may have agreed on that if it was Jaye or even Mallory but neither of them have any relation with MC of Chasing Sunset. At best they are side girls, most likely they are just friends of MC. :confused::unsure: I am confused now.
 

WICKEDp4th

Before Alice went to Wonderland, she had to fall.
Donor
Sep 6, 2017
3,356
5,696
I may have agreed on that if it was Jaye or even Mallory but neither of them have any relation with MC of Chasing Sunset. At best they are side girls, most likely they are just friends of MC. :confused::unsure: I am confused now.
I know. ;)
But they are part of the cast and story, therefore they are bound to the MC of CS and his dick. Some people swing that way, i guess.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nurikabe

BigBlueDude

Member
Nov 15, 2020
212
702
I understand that people like to have a variety of playthroughs.

On my first playthrough of CS - I built full trust and love with Jaye early on - and she was a virgin who waited for the MC for their first time.

I also played later with a different focus for the MC/Jaye, breaking trust with Jaye - I was not shocked At all when she was not a virgin when she and the MC had their first time.

I like a story where there is consequence for the actions of the MC.

I don't understand those who complained that Jaye was not a virgin the first time she and the MC had sex when their choices did not create the bond of trust that Jaye needed to remain faithful to a hope (one she still held).

If this is what some people required of Jaye - her virginity for the MC - create a new playthrough - isn't that what replayability is all about?

Does the story still streamline (no ability to expand the primary LI roster beyond Jaye/Mallory) so we end up with less 'choice' than some of us want - sure.

I'll take that over a 1 year = 1 release dev cycle though.

Cheers!! :coffee:
Oh wow.

I didnt know my headcanon was canon if you played a certain way. In my main playthrough i played high trust with Jaye. Internally it made more sense to me based on the childhood and parental loving family dynamic that genuine respect would be a factor and much of the trust is in regards to the business so it just grew high there, while love was lagging behind. (nurtured a hope to bag Tara somewhere along the line)

I took it for granted that Jaye had dated like any normal person in the years of zero contact and growing into a new person. And now i learned that if trust is low she actually did what my headcanon says she should have done. Thank you!
 

BeingADikDik

Engaged Member
Apr 17, 2021
2,106
6,027
All this incel yapping overlooks the obvious narrative risk. If the reader is meant to believe that new MC succeeds where old MC fails for Tara/Lisa, then the onus is on the devs to make it convincing. If new MC is subjectively less attractive than old MC or otherwise less appealing, cognitive dissonance from having played this game may overshadow immersion in the new narrative. I know I wouldn't be able to take the new game seriously if I thought the relationships with established characters were not believably motivated given their historical contexts.

This is why I hold it is safer to separate the main casts between games.
 
4.60 star(s) 324 Votes