Cause we weren't committed to anyone when we slept with Mal, and told her it was just helping her, we committed to Jaye later, so no, we didn't betray her. And I have no clue what you are saying about Amanda being present
Mal follows Amanda to MC's room in the first place that night and Amanda stays there until the end, masturbating on the floor. I did not say she was involved with them in bed just that she was present in the room. The threesome happens later of course. Funny you're saying I'm the one who did not play the game.
Also, I did not say MC was committed to Jaye but they were involved in multiple ways already and MC DID say before that he wasn't involved with anyone else. If you tell a girl that you're not seeing anybody then spend the night with her naked in her bed then almost fuck her in the morning in the shower after a 16 years long very complicated past with deep feelings for each other and then you go and fuck another girl within days, you shouldn't be surprised when said girl dumps you right away, explicitly committed or not.
1. MC lied to Jaye at least from Jaye's POW. Even if it was true when MC has said it, Jaye saw them kissing the first time she met Mal then MC told her it was nothing then somehow it became something. Why wouldn't she think there was something between them from the beginning and MC just lied to her?
2. MC fucked another woman after something already started between them.
I would say MC betrayed Jaye's trust and didn't even bother to tell Jaye about Mal, she found out by accident when running into Mal while both were on the way to his room. Mal on the other hand knew about the Jaye situation from the beginning, MC didn't even have to say anything so it's understandable that she won't make that big of a deal of MC and Jaye.
Would you be OK with a girl doing the same to you, lying about other guys and fucking one the day after your encounter with her? Would you get into a poly relationship with the girl and the other dude? I somehow doubt that...
I'm genuinely amazed this needs an explanation.
The other part is mainly just a difference in opinion but the story is a lot more focused around Jaye and her relationship with MC. They have a past, grew up together, are shown a lot more together even as little children. They both just lost their parents so share the grief and they have a role in the future of the company together.
Even if you, the player, never liked Jaye, the story explicitly tells us that MC was in love with her, left home because of his feelings for her, fucked lots of green-eyed redheads after leaving home because they reminded him of her and therefore he was attracted to them simply because he still had feelings for her etc.
MC's feelings for Jaye are not decided only by the player, the same isn't true for Mal, it's possible to always be rude to her and then there won't be a single line that implicates any feelings towards her. She has a very important part of the story even then and surely is a main LI but I don't think she's Jaye's equal in this story, at least I don't feel like devs made her that way.
This does not mean some players can't like her more than Jaye of course, I like her character too.