Why would Jamie not be a virgin? It defeats the whole point of her character if she just fucked some random guy, not to mention her relationship with the MC. I would say that it's also inconsistent with how she's written at the beginning of the game.
This game is so close to being great, but there are a number of asinine things like this that drag it way, way down.
She is clearly promiscuous , even if she acts innocent at first . She mastrubates , she is in to public sex , has multiple sex toys and she is an atrractive young woman. Thats not the mind set of a virgin. I say if she was a virgin then she has something wrong with her , since clearly she is not anti-social or a-sexual. "Her relationship with the MC" !? So she shoud wait for him not even not knowing if he will ever be back in his home town , not knowing even then if he will make a move on her ? That's borderline psychotic. Maybe you want her to have little shire of carboard cut outs of the MC , hidding in the closed ? The girl is fine as she is , she reminds me of
Jamie Palamino from the movie "Just friends" it whoud have been super wierd if she confested to Reynolds character that she has been saving herself all these years for him and she is still a virgin.