- Jun 18, 2022
- 315
- 2,176
Right, I don't see how a Lucy who is really after a rich and powerful man would ever be happy with Edward for very long no matter how much he lies and pretends. Surely the deception would fall apart like a house of cards over time. Does he expect Elsa to bankroll the whole affair even once Lucy starts wanting more and more from him? Will he know when practice is over (yuck) and it's time to dump her? When things do collapse, he'll then have a hostile neighbor who'll be willing to tell every other woman who shows up at his apartment about the kind of person he really is. It's also perhaps not really the best idea to anger someone who works in the PM's office. The whole situation seems way more likely to blow up badly in Edward's face than end well even if it boosts his confidence in the short term.I really wonder what the plan for this character is. Because if she ends up being a gold digger, then she seriously needs to start digging already, because she hasn't gotten much of anything, yet. If she ends up as an actual romantic option, then I wonder how that's going to fit into the story, if Edward eventually manages to get closer to Alice.
On the other hand, it has always made sense to me that Edward could have made Lucy into a gold digger purely in his mind since she really didn't seem to be that kind of person in their initial interactions and Ed's thinking is often misguided and impulsive. The head-scratcher as you noted is why Lucy ultimately only responds positively when Edward playacts and treats her poorly. She never seems like a gold digger to me until the moment when Ed makes some bizarre deductive leap and suddenly decides she is one. Will it turn out to be bad writing because she seems so inconsistent as a character or good writing because it shows us how skewed Edward's perception of things really is?
If she isn't the person he thinks she is, then it's still possible that being honest and semi-kind to her will pay off in the very long run and the alpha/asshole path will end in utter failure. Then again, they just might not be a very good fit for each other on either path and perhaps no amount of either honesty or deception will change that. That's certainly realistic even if it does cheat us out of the only thicc love interest.
I'm with you on the non-Randian redemption arc. If Edward ends up in a hopeful, healthy place at the end of the game, I'll count it as a win even if he's completely alone. However, I think Alice has potential to be more than a trophy wife -- she's not my favorite LI, but they're pretty good together and I could see him growing into a better person thanks to her challenging and encouraging him.I still really want the redemption arc for Edward that doesn't involve him being the protagonist of an Ayn Rand novel and I could see how other LIs stacking up against his chosen trophy wife could be the catalyst.