1. If you are gossiping with a woman in a bar you are probably trying to seduce her instead of watching her gangbanged by randos.
Why would you be trying to seduce a woman you can already have sex with?
In fact, she also has a regular TALK option. The gossip button is completely separate from both talk and sex.
2. Wait, this scene is triggered by using a [gossip] button? Why would players assume that [gossip] button will result in Cait making you watch her being gangbanged? dialog options should not be a complete surprise where they just spring a fetish on you without warning.
The dialog tells you (and I believe Cait does too) that Cait is getting madder and madder and is going to do stuff. ANd, as someone reminded me, Cait actually gradually escalates to that point.
3. where does the whole
come into play then if you are the one who has to initiate the scene? Or is it only initiated randomly when you click the [gossip] button?
Not only do you have to press the button enough times to see a 1/76 event several times that gradually escalates, the scene is able to be opted out of I'm almost positive.
But if there is a button to have sex with her, then she is your girlfriend/lover and not some random enemy you are not in a relationship with.
You've...played this game, right? You can have sex with people immediately after learning their names.
Scenario:
A. player meets this girl in the bar. clicks on the sex button. they have sex. Keep doing it a few times.
B. player decides they want to get to know their girlfriend better to be more than just sex friends. clicks [gossip] button to get to know the character better and see the dialog.
C. they keep on doing [gossip] until suddenly boom. forced to watch her gangbanged by other dudes.
This... is just classic straightforwards NTR then.
You don't meet her in the bar. She's part of a pack of roving bandits ("mercenaries") who go around robbing and raping people. In fact, she continues to attempt to rob and rape you even after you guys meet in the bar, and makes clear she plans to continue doing so next time she catches you outside. She is not in any way your girlfriend.
Gossip doesn't "get to know her better". She mostly talks shit about various people. In fact, every companion she talks shit about has an escalating series of responses to her. (Cait makes her do sluttier and sluttier things, Arona tosses her against a wall and shoves her dick in her face, Berwyn...barks at her, etc).
It's just not at all NTR situation, and it has to be dug
deeply and repeatedly for by the player.