Thats fair, but even it being bad roleplay is different than it being vanilla. It still means that most scenes aren't actually something I'd be interested in reading. Speaking in vague generalities, first you have to remember that I will only find less than half the characters attractive in the first place because I'm straight, then some percentage of the girls are actually trans, or have gigantic uncomfortably large knockers, or have personalities like bimbos or whatever that are unattractive.
So now of the 30% of NPCs I actually ~might~ enjoy, they each get some amount of scenes, but even those have some subset of things I wouldn't like. Magical transformations, a scene where you plant eggs in their eyes, milking, whatever.
If you drew it all out as a percentage it ends up being like what, 20% of all scenes have something I like in them? That is an awfully small percentage of total content and it means I feel like I'm dodging landmines when playing because I can't reliably find content I enjoy without putting in effort to do so.
It prevents me from enjoying the game an awful lot.
Though that said, thats why I'd prefer some OTHER game that was like CoC but more for me. It wouldn't be right for me to argue that this game should be different to better suit me, there are plenty of people who like this game the way it is. But for me personally the game has som eproblems that really diminish it overall.