I do not see how her fucking everyone contradicts her falling for you. From what I understand, you will get to be in more open relationship with her, in which both of you get to fuck whoever you want, but you have special place in her heart. As you do for her. The classic case of differing lust from love. Most people are not into it, but I do not find that a flaw.
As for whole anal virgin thing. I think it is a common trope in smut where anal is reserved for special people. Not sure why, but it exists.
And Ryn does not want to lose her dick to feel more like a girl. Only reason she wanted to lose it is to get rid of that cursed cage.
As WolffamL said on forums.
"If you talk to Ryn enough, it's clear that she's perfectly fine with having a penis and doesn't want to get rid of it (the Champ suggesting she remove it to remove the cage is met with horror) and talking to her post-WC makes it clear that she doesn't
want a vagina. Her being half-sexed meant decades of misery under Alissa but it's part of who she
is, she doesn't want to change that and Savin's made it clear that it's never happening... but she might be able to grow her little twig into a fat elvish yule log at some point after the cage comes of. Currently she can be given TFing items to increase her breast and ass size; that's something she's fine with."
You must be registered to see the links
Dude wrote Hretha, Harpy leader and that Hellhound. While he may prefer anal, he still writes plenty of vaginal content.