Best I can do is incredible hunk, but only with cait and only in one scene.
Not a stat boost, rather something like trait/badge that relates to the way player dealt with X situation.
Like, lumberjack situation can be resolved:
beating whats her name again
player receive trait/badge 'scourge of nature' which provides bonus damage/crit against animals/plants.
asking BROTHER CAPTAIN GABRIEL ANGELOS to talk her out
player receive trait/badge 'peace of a mind' which provides bonuses for companions.
resolve it peacefully on your own
trait/badge 'psycho_the_rapist' which gives...I dunno protection against divine based magical attacks????
So the further game progresses the more stat page looked like an actual consequences of players actions, a la