Tsubuhaza

Active Member
Sep 28, 2020
528
2,215
Oh most definitely people here hated Etheryn's quest. Especially when it forces you to take it up the butt from her to get the romantic closure people has been asking for years.
To be fair, wasn't there a shindig about how she wanted to be a full lady or something until she just didn't? Think there was some convoluted reply to that question too.

Gotta say, a while back I hunted down the newest version of the xianxia mod for the original coc. Not a huge fan of the xianxia genre generally, but it was still far more enjoyable than playing through coc2 on a new character. There's just so much shit in coc2 that I don't really care about but feel like I'll be missing out on something if I don't do it regardless.
The only thing I felt coc2 had going for it was that it's...shinier? I guess?
I mean... it has art, I guess? Would also say no Urta but I think the sequel got that field covered generously.

Please, don't get Tobs to write another moderate length novel about agrarian kitsune traditions!
Too late, a bust for Karl-tsune Marx is already in production.
 

Alterism

Active Member
Feb 17, 2019
528
3,728
Tbf was never really a thing, just wishful thinking.
Mostly. She's properly referring to her gender as half-sexed are referred as female. If the dialogue was just what she says post-cage nobody would have been confused at all.


and

And so on.
You could probably make a mental leap that her steps to completely rid herself of her dick is more a factor of how much she hated the cage rather than how little she cared about her dick.


Where people get justifiably tripped (and I could swear I've talked about this before) are things like this



and



Doesn't mind being TF'd. Likes having the champions ideal figure? A person could reasonably make inferences to the extent she'd go.

And I swear this debate is comically lopsided for these games and 9/10 only ever goes one way.
A female? She can get a dick. Half the crew in TiTS can have dicks stapled onto them. Multiple non crew also have dicks stapled onto them.

But a dickgirl getting a vagina? Hold the phone now. Let's not get too crazy here.
 

glygoch

Member
Apr 27, 2017
119
244
It's a metric in a world where women can have both sets of genitals or either. It's perfectly in tune with the logic of the setting.
If genitals are not at all tied to womanhood or anything, then she has no reason not to at least temporarily switch them, like clothes.
That being said, there is no point discussing the "logic" of it or dig through dialogue to find evidence of something, when we all know it could happen tommorow if the devs wanted.
 

Skandranon

Well-Known Member
Nov 28, 2016
1,548
3,689
If genitals are not at all tied to womanhood or anything, then she has no reason not to at least temporarily switch them, like clothes.
She doesn't want to? Womanhood doesn't have to have anything to do with it. Same reason you as a player might not want to despite it being even easier.

That being said, there is no point discussing the "logic" of it or dig through dialogue to find evidence of something, when we all know it could happen tommorow if the devs wanted.
I agree with this, though. Dev doesn't want his character to go a certain way, and that's all there really is to be said about it.
 

Biostar

Well-Known Member
Aug 4, 2017
1,194
5,747
The game is made by people that interact and have writers in trans community. So it makes sense that Ryn is treated no different than Brienne and Kiyoko when it comes to her womanhood.
It's a metric in a world where women can have both sets of genitals or either. It's perfectly in tune with the logic of the setting.
Then why does that line exist at all then? Why would she need anything to feel like a woman? This is the part that doesn't gel with this rainbow mentality.
 

GokutheG

Well-Known Member
Oct 20, 2022
1,562
3,044
Where people get justifiably tripped (and I could swear I've talked about this before) are things like this

Yeah this was the first time I felt the writing concerning her felt off. I couldn't tell if she felt that her penis somehow made her less than a woman even tho elves have a sex where women have them. It doesn't come off as her only being upset over the cage.

I'm not sure this was the intent but it made me think that she was originally a guy and part of her sister's abuse was the cage and taking away his gender.
 
Dec 26, 2018
104
504
I don't think there's a single character between coc2 and TiTS that matches how great Amily and Urta were in CoC.
It's cause for the most part CoC's character's were free to interact with and react to the other characters in the game (player included). I'm not holding these characters are some paragons of writing, they weren't. But the authors actually tried to make their characters feel like they were part of the greater world and its narratives. The player could have different types of relationships with the same characters, giving them more dimensions and nuance than standard locked in routes. And subsequent updates and mods increased the level of crossover and character interactions to even greater heights.

CoC2 and TiTS suffer badly from the authors basically sandboxing many of their characters to specific locations and situations. These games remind us that "donut steel" is not just the default name of the player character in TiTS, but the default mentality that most mediocre furry and erotica writers have when making OCs. As a result the CoC2 authors clearly shield their creations from the player and greater story in ways that are to the detriment of the story and its readers. Some of these authors have argued that it's for the sake of a more consistent and realistic characterization, but really it's because they overidentify with these characters and can't bear to see these characters acting in ways they don't like. Meanwhile CoC1 actually let the players have far more freedom in how they interacted with the characers, and it elevated their characterization because you could see how the characters acted with regards to different situations and people.

It's natural for writers to be attached to their characters. But authors who want to actually write a good story need to be able to distance themselves from their creations somewhat and look at the bigger picture. I think DnD is a great comparison to this kind of game actually when it comes to priorities in writing. People who have been lucky enough to find themselves in good DnD/ttrpg groups know that the best DMs are the ones who don't try to insert themselves into the story as much but instead do their best to craft a story for the players to have fun in. Bad DMs often act like another player who happens to have God Mode enabled, and the players just grow bored and frustrated as they realize they're fighting some neckbeard's ego the whole time. That's what CoC2 feels like, and it fucking sucks.
 
2.90 star(s) 127 Votes