VN Ren'Py Completed Dating My Daughter [Ch. 1-4 v1.01] [MrDots Games]

[claus001]

At the start D comes across as an 11 year old mentally with giant tits. She's completely oblivious, naive, and let's be honest, quite dumb. And from day one it's also obvious that PervDad realises this about her, and then just spews wordsalads at her to confuse her into letting him do what he wants to her. All that is to say that a optional ending where PervDad loses out completely at the end and all the girls leave him would make me happy, but I don't expect it to happen nor do I feel _that_ strongly about it.

Amen! This was also the reason why I dropped this game: I felt like I was exploiting a handicapped child with giant boobs. The most common problems with Father-Daughter incest games are the father is a sexual predator, the whole escalation is built upon "the bathroom door was unlocked and I found x hot" or the daughter is really messed up without a good reason and wants to bone dad for reasons.

A pro-tip to incest game makers: there were historical nations where incest was legal and expected. You can borrow that material and have a rather exotic game without making it weird.

 

[Amahl Farouk]

I always thought pervdad was fucked up from day 1, lol. The way he always wordsalads daughter to rationalise sexual moves he makes towards her really felt like a twisted abuser taking advantage of an incredibly dimwitted girl. I wonder what that makes me for still fapping to it tho ;p.

Either way a route where Daughter realises her dad is a sick and twisted manipulator and does something with her life would be nice, but it's not likely to happen.

She is doing something worthwhile with her life! She is getting banged stupid by her loving father! And, loving every minute of it I might add!

 

[Irgendwie Irgendwo]

Speaking of assumptions and such? Wasn't there supposed to be a scene on a Yacht? At least I remember posting the picture of a garden tool since somebody thought there were hoes on the boat.

Was that scene on a path that I'm not following, namely Sharing Martin or Jennifer?

 

[jamdan]

Colour me confused. So we're going to an evening event in an obvious swinger club (and everybody with half a brain would have seen that coming from a mile away) and then there is no swinging going on, and most people do not want to be there in the first place, or even if they wanted to be there were not interested in the purpose of being there. And the only one, on two of the three possible paths, getting any is Daddy Dearest, as usual.

Third thing, in relation with a question. Q first: Is Rosa the Virginity Snatcher Nanny? Now for the issue. As far as I remember the MrDots Universe has established that Melody plays several years after DMD. In Sunshine Love, Melody is an established Superstar, which obviously takes some time too. Now we meet Trisha, in a backstory as a hair stylist that has not been established yet, who is about to apply for a management position for the mayor candidate's office, and the candidate is about to run. Granted, we don't know how long said mayor is in office, but somehow the timeline does not add up for me.

Final point, and it's a positive one, a sex scene during a car wash was new to me. An original idea, props for that.

The swinger club was a complete waste of time. I understand the other couple getting cold feet and leaving. That happens sometimes...but they didn't need to exist in the first place.

Personally, I think they were attempting to pander to anti-sharing crowd and not offend them too much. One of the "keys" was completely pointless. The other was swapping daughters, which should've been interesting however... maybe I don't have a great memory, but I'm pretty sure Graham has been interested in D before. But now, in a swinger club of all places...he isn't? So that route was just a socially-distanced handjob with Graham/D while Olivia fucks F. Which wasn't even as interesting as the first time they hooked up together in Ch3. And the final key was more or less an identical copy of that Ch3 event, where D/F bang and Olivia is participating on the side. The only difference is Graham banged Olivia from behind instead of jerking on the couch.

D has done one proper 4-some, with Margo and Ryan, this event should've been the same with Graham & Olivia. But they had to invent a reason to not do that. When Olivia first got pregnant and her and Graham were roleplaying, Olivia asks him if he likes D. If he says yes, she roleplays as D for him. So let's not pretend that Graham has never been interested in D. He goggled her at the nudist beach too.

D being hesitant or nervous doesn't make any sense either. She enjoyed the 4-some with Ryan/Olivia. She banged F on the beach with that bartender guy watching. She's lusting over Martin. She's already done, at least some, sexual activity with Olivia/Graham before. Hell, she had an option beforehand to not wear underwear. Which was totally pointless.

The writers don't review the script, and they don't plan ahead. And you can tell in this update.

 

[IceNeo2]

I have to ask do I need to download the previous chapters along with the latest version to play the whole game? Or just the latest version which include all the previous chapters?

 

[Irgendwie Irgendwo]

I have to ask do I need to download the previous chapters along with the latest version to play the whole game? Or just the latest version which include all the previous chapters?

All of the chapters have to be downloaded, otherwise you'd start with just C4.

 

[Xolvath]

any save 100%

 

[cartmancop1980]

Speaking of assumptions and such? Wasn't there supposed to be a scene on a Yacht? At least I remember posting the picture of a garden tool since somebody thought there were hoes on the boat.

Was that scene on a path that I'm not following, namely Sharing Martin or Jennifer?

Looking at walkthrough that’s if u don’t go to club with Olivia and graham

 

[Diconica]

At the start D comes across as an 11 year old mentally with giant tits. She's completely oblivious, naive, and let's be honest, quite dumb. And from day one it's also obvious that PervDad realises this about her, and then just spews wordsalads at her to confuse her into letting him do what he wants to her. All that is to say that a optional ending where PervDad loses out completely at the end and all the girls leave him would make me happy, but I don't expect it to happen nor do I feel _that_ strongly about it.

There really isn't any strong character building in this game. There is none at the start and not really much throughout the game even.

Dad worked in an office with some people we know and was responsible for some reports. I don't even remember if he had a job title or what the report types were.
About the most we know of the daughter is she was helpful in organizing the reports on the computer.
There wasn't any real goals or ambitions laid out or anything of real importance before hand.
About the only consistency in character building in the game was the father wanting to fuck the daughter and the daughter and modeling.
You don't see any real growth in personality or learn anything about likes, dislikes that are strong that influence their thoughts.

All in all the characters are like hollow shells of people.
The reason is probably because the author spent to much time on side parts of the story rather than just focus on the primary story and characters.
At present we know almost as much about the other father and daughter in the game as the two main characters and they are side characters.
It wouldn't be that way if he wrote the entirety of the primary story first and focused on the two main characters then when that was completed gone back and added in the side stories.

At this point I don't think the author is invested any in the story itself and is more just trying to milk the project for money from fans. Which is what is governing what content he is adding and other choices.

 

[Joey's Conscience]

So I'm planning to write a review for this game, but there's something I'd like to clarify. So I rejected male sharing in my playthrough, so I don't know exactly the context. But I did check the sharing scenes out of curiosity from the mod's gallery.
From the dialogue, it seems like rather than being just an "adventure" to spice things up, the daughter starts having feelings for other dudes (even on my playthough, I could see the game trying to create sexual tension, but I didn't expect her to straight up say "I love you" to Martin, like wtf), and dad kinda just rolls with it because he just does whatever she wants.
So, is that pretty much how it goes? Or the father has more of an active role than I think? Because I think there's a pretty big difference between a casual adventure, and her falling "in love" with any dude that swings a dick at her face.

 

[Ooh]

Amen! This was also the reason why I dropped this game: I felt like I was exploiting a handicapped child with giant boobs. The most common problems with Father-Daughter incest games are the father is a sexual predator, the whole escalation is built upon "the bathroom door was unlocked and I found x hot" or the daughter is really messed up without a good reason and wants to bone dad for reasons.

A pro-tip to incest game makers: there were historical nations where incest was legal and expected. You can borrow that material and have a rather exotic game without making it weird.

I didnt really drop it but I definitely felt the creepy grooming vibe which turned me off. There is another game on this site with a super hot daughter where overtime I grew bored/annoyed with the MC and started to hope the D would cuck him. But now Im starting to see if was mostly being bored with the ridiculous writing and tropes you mentioned. Youre absolutely right, why dont they just google it and rip it off from a real society. D is still smoking hot and I love the smooth animations in this game. Cant watch her get banged enough especially after what you had to endure in the early chapters. Perhaps ppl dont remember all the blueballing, game over screens, being penalized for hugging or kissing her too soon, Love points. Cmon man, bare minimum she should get her brains banged out each update.

 

[Ooh]

So I'm planning to write a review for this game, but there's something I'd like to clarify. So I rejected male sharing in my playthrough, so I don't know exactly the context. But I did check the sharing scenes out of curiosity from the mod's gallery.
From the dialogue, it seems like rather than being just an "adventure" to spice things up, the daughter starts having feelings for other dudes (even on my playthough, I could see the game trying to create sexual tension, but I didn't expect her to straight up say "I love you" to Martin, like wtf), and dad kinda just rolls with it because he just does whatever she wants.
So, is that pretty much how it goes? Or the father has more of an active role than I think? Because I think there's a pretty big difference between a casual adventure, and her falling "in love" with any dude that swings a dick at her face.

You pretty much narrowed it down. There is an "I love you" but she grew attached to Martin overtime with some of the things he's done for her. Yoga, helping them move, keeping the secret safe. Wouldn't be surprised if the D also drops the L word on Graham or Koko.

 

[Diconica]

You pretty much narrowed it down. There is an "I love you" but she grew attached to Martin overtime with some of the things he's done for her. Yoga, helping them move, keeping the secret safe. Wouldn't be surprised if the D also drops the L word on Graham or Koko.

Got to say I haven't played the sharing part either glad as hell I didn't now.

She falls in love because a friend helps out with some stuff. rofl.

Don't friends usually help each other out and keep one another secrets. Kind of he definition of friend.
It's not like this is a nightingale effect where someone cared for the person or saved their life.
The serious emotional immaturity in this is nauseating to say the least.
The question is it the character representing this or the author.
This reminds me of all the immature shits I knew in middle school who thought doing nice things for girls would get them ahead.
I think I'll go change my rating and drop it down a star now that I know it stuff this sad in it.

 

[Joey's Conscience]

Got to say I haven't played the sharing part either glad as hell I didn't now.

She falls in love because a friend helps out with some stuff. rofl.

Don't friends usually help each other out and keep one another secrets. Kind of he definition of friend.
It's not like this is a nightingale effect where someone cared for the person or saved their life.
The serious emotional immaturity in this is nauseating to say the least.
The question is it the character representing this or the author.
This reminds me of all the immature shits I knew in middle school who thought doing nice things for girls would get them ahead.
I think I'll go change my rating and drop it down a star now that I know it stuff this sad in it.

Yeah, the tone of both Martin and Ryan's scenes surprised the shit out of me. I was expecting the sharing path to be on the lines of "really secure dad wants to spice up things and proposes a casual threeway with another dude, and daughter accepts because she does what daddy wants". Didn't expect her to be the one leading, having feelings, while dad is being insecure, and just accepting it.
Kinda puts into question everything that happened before. Does she actually love dad, or she's just that easy, and it just happend that he was the first dude to grope her tits? And why would a guy that gave up his house, his job, his savings, and a relationship with a model to be with his daughter, just give her up like that? Other than him having no self worth, that is?
After all the lovey-dovey in ch 1 and 2, this feels so out of place to me.

 

[Icy]

if you want D all to yourself yes you can turn off all sharing routes even the lesbian ones which means all you'll see is F penetrating her enjoy!

I was being sarcastic.
Someone said he stopped playing because one of routes had sharing.

 

[JotaroKaneki]

A dumb question but do I need to download previous chapters to play chapter 4?

 

[tata19]

The swinger club was a complete waste of time. I understand the other couple getting cold feet and leaving. That happens sometimes...but they didn't need to exist in the first place.

Personally, I think they were attempting to pander to anti-sharing crowd and not offend them too much. One of the "keys" was completely pointless. The other was swapping daughters, which should've been interesting however... maybe I don't have a great memory, but I'm pretty sure Graham has been interested in D before. But now, in a swinger club of all places...he isn't? So that route was just a socially-distanced handjob with Graham/D while Olivia fucks F. Which wasn't even as interesting as the first time they hooked up together in Ch3. And the final key was more or less an identical copy of that Ch3 event, where D/F bang and Olivia is participating on the side. The only difference is Graham banged Olivia from behind instead of jerking on the couch.

D has done one proper 4-some, with Margo and Ryan, this event should've been the same with Graham & Olivia. But they had to invent a reason to not do that. When Olivia first got pregnant and her and Graham were roleplaying, Olivia asks him if he likes D. If he says yes, she roleplays as D for him. So let's not pretend that Graham has never been interested in D. He goggled her at the nudist beach too.

D being hesitant or nervous doesn't make any sense either. She enjoyed the 4-some with Ryan/Olivia. She banged F on the beach with that bartender guy watching. She's lusting over Martin. She's already done, at least some, sexual activity with Olivia/Graham before. Hell, she had an option beforehand to not wear underwear. Which was totally pointless.

The writers don't review the script, and they don't plan ahead. And you can tell in this update.

agree with you with everything you say. the club scene is totally incongruous after another. Why the choice of wearing underwear or not? And the 3 keys to end a scene already seen and Graham is stupid or what? She invites them to a swingers club and then tells D that he doesn't want to be with her is totally unintelligible.

 

[Yamakasi20]

yeah, Graham writing is just hilariously bad...

Olivia says she loves watching Graham fuck other girls, Graham fucks other girls, but when D comes offering herself on the table with her dad's approval (sigh...), Graham is like "oh oh, plot armor girl... dont wanna upset the social justice warriors".

Pretty sure we are more than 90% here who would love seeing D leave her dad in the dirt
(because, believe it or not, i play this for PORN...).

 

[SoiCowboy]

I didnt really drop it but I definitely felt the creepy grooming vibe which turned me off. There is another game on this site with a super hot daughter where overtime I grew bored/annoyed with the MC and started to hope the D would cuck him. But now Im starting to see if was mostly being bored with the ridiculous writing and tropes you mentioned. Youre absolutely right, why dont they just google it and rip it off from a real society. D is still smoking hot and I love the smooth animations in this game. Cant watch her get banged enough especially after what you had to endure in the early chapters. Perhaps ppl dont remember all the blueballing, game over screens, being penalized for hugging or kissing her too soon, Love points. Cmon man, bare minimum she should get her brains banged out each update.

I'm hoping for her to "tip" the pizza delivery guy!

 

[Ooh]

yeah, Graham writing is just hilariously bad...

Olivia says she loves watching Graham fuck other girls, Graham fucks other girls, but when D comes offering herself on the table with her dad's approval (sigh...), Graham is like "oh oh, plot armor girl... dont wanna upset the social justice warriors".

Pretty sure we are more than 90% here who would love seeing D leave her dad in the dirt
(because, believe it or not, i play this for PORN...).

Amen brother. Preach! Doing the lords work.