I wonder which kind of lights is better for that scene
View attachment 1160774
View attachment 1160775
Normally some nice lighting and shadows improve an image, but in this particular case not necessarily.
Is this a game or just an image? If a game, then it is important to consider the game as a whole.
If you prefer to have the version with the natural light, consider either moving the angle or making it a bit more yellow. When the sun makes so long shadows, it is rarely so white. (Actually, this might be too white even for noon.)
And these (long) shadows give me a more "epic" feeling, so the question is what you want to convey? Is this a fun scene where the girl is playing football or is this the last chance to score and win the match of her life?
Maybe even rotating the light source counterclockwise would be good to give her back a bit of light as well.