So for me, sex scene is an important aspect, the key of porn games. But what the people think of the utmost important of porn games ? ... for the start, what do you think important the most ?
a. Sex Scene - b. Story - c. Asset (3D model & Environment, Character appearance & clothing) d. Faster Release.
For me, what really matter is the most difficult part, the writing. The story can lack of depth, the dialogs can lack of constancy, the CG be average, if the writing is good, I'll be hooked to the game. Just because, despite it's possible flaws, a good written game forms a coherent ensemble, and the radiating feelings achieve to build a bond between the player (at least me) and the game. It's the case by example for
You must be registered to see the links
. The game can be better. The dialogs sometimes feel strange, the CG can have been more polished, but there's this little something in the writing which make you have feelings for the characters.
After this came the dialogs, too many games with a possibly interesting story fall because of totally unrealistic dialogs ; it's the case of
You must be registered to see the links
. The CG are good, the story have potential, but the dialogs are so incredible that I can't find it interesting ; it feel like a fan fiction wrote by a 13 years old princess. It's also an example of bad writing. This moment where the main character send her sister out of the room because she'll remove her clothes... and let her sister enter again when she's with just her underwear. The author don't though deep enough about the whole scene. That the MC don't want to change in front of her sister, alright, but not in this particular case. They planed to sleep together, sharing the same bed, and just agreed, not reluctantly, that they'll sleep in their underwear. So, no, in real life you'll not send your sister out of the room while you just remove your shirt and skirt.
Then come the accuracy between the CG and the scene, but not necessarily in a "realistic" way. I prefer a game with average CG, but where the pictures are part of the action and their details tell you something, than a story with amazing CG but which are just like painting used to justify the "visual" in "visual novel". Take
You must be registered to see the links
, by example. The 3D can be better, but there's a scene where you know exactly what one of the character think, just by looking at her eyes. The eyes... This and the mouth, are the most forgot parts of the body. Whatever the character is happy, ashamed, frustrated, angry, or whatever else, they are always looking right in front of them... And when the mouth change, most of the time it's on the portrait, not on the scene itself. At least with 3D CG, when it come to 2D, there's more use of these two parts which tell so many thing about the situation.
And finally come the CG, whatever 3D or 2D. But if good CG can make me like an average game, they need to be really bad to make me dislike a good game. I'm here to use my brain, if I just wanted to fap, there's tons of porn movies, porn comics, and fast fapping flash games around there. No, if I play an adult game, whatever it's a porn one or an erotic one, it's for something else. And just good CG can't give it to me.
All this said, it's my preferences. I know that there's people who put the story in first place, other need good dialogs. It's a question of personal taste and it depend of the reason you play such games. For the same reason, I fully understand that, because of your past, a good CG with realistic scenes can be, for you, the "something else" I talked about.
