Herapa

Active Member
Donor
Sep 10, 2017
880
685
I mean, the Apparition know of the Book, why they don't know what's in that Book (or just faking it)? They so willingly help us in the Dream World, they give us the tainted shard, show us the story of the Prophet. Why are they bound to us (or are they bound to us), we used the tainted shard on aunt, right? What keeps them bound to us then?
 

Baka_Energy_studios

Engaged Member
Game Developer
Aug 31, 2017
2,579
5,760
I mean, the Apparition know of the Book, why they don't know what's in that Book (or just faking it)? They so willingly help us in the Dream World, they give us the tainted shard, show us the story of the Prophet. Why are they bound to us (or are they bound to us), we used the tainted shard on aunt, right? What keeps them bound to us then?
i bet it´s the pokemon card collection ...very valuable stuff;)
 

John The Boogeyman Wick

Active Member
Jul 12, 2017
618
690
I mean, the Apparition know of the Book, why they don't know what's in that Book (or just faking it)? They so willingly help us in the Dream World, they give us the tainted shard, show us the story of the Prophet. Why are they bound to us (or are they bound to us), we used the tainted shard on aunt, right? What keeps them bound to us then?
There is a "chosen one" story arc going on here. I think the MC is their agent in the real world and manipulating him by giving him what he wants. But do you notice there always seems to be price for his services, like "find this shard".
 
  • Like
Reactions: Herapa

Herapa

Active Member
Donor
Sep 10, 2017
880
685
There is a "chosen one" story arc going on here. I think the MC is their agent in the real world and manipulating him by giving him what he wants. But do you notice there always seems to be price for his services, like "find this shard".
Yeah, like the Order sends the Spell to MC, Tracy finds out about it (via the short haired woman), asks aunt to keep Alice away (not to get tainted by MC), works with the shorted haired woman to fight the Order. The short haired woman uses the Spell on Trace to block answering questions about the Spell and the Order, as she sees that MC could grow brains and ask her. Tracy steals the work done by MC for mom and hides it, so the MC would be distracted and wouldn't use the Spell on his family (that backfired for sure).
 

Herapa

Active Member
Donor
Sep 10, 2017
880
685
What if Tracy is using the spell on the MC, and he doesn't know
We don't know if it works on male... but I have suspicion that she used it... as MC ended up in Dream World, and when MC asked the Apparition for some answers, they said that they are needed elsewhere and left... so yeah I think Tracy (or someone) used the Spell on MC.
 
  • Like
Reactions: volto

Herapa

Active Member
Donor
Sep 10, 2017
880
685
At one of the playthroughs I was so suspicious about everybody that even thought that Mom and Marcus are part of the conspiracy. Not to mention "not the sharpest tool in the shed" - Abigail, she invites MC (a virgin) on a date out of the blue... This game so winds me up.. like nothing else out there :D
 

John The Boogeyman Wick

Active Member
Jul 12, 2017
618
690
At one of the playthroughs I was so suspicious about everybody that even thought that Mom and Marcus are part of the conspiracy. Not to mention "not the sharpest tool in the shed" - Abigail, she invites MC (a virgin) on a date out of the blue... This game so winds me up.. like nothing else out there :D
MOM? I never thought she was suspicious "she an angle:angel::heartcoveredeyes:".
As for suspicion of the rest
Aunt, is smart and knows that there is power at work but I don't know how much she knows?
Marcus, is a possibility but I think hes loyal to the MC.
Tracy, knows more than she lets on but I think she think she protecting the family.
Alice, is innocent as you could be.
Latisha, defiantly a no.
Abigail, I think is innocent and naive but something make me think she to know more than she lets on.
Knew chick, I don't trust but I need more context.
I think I've made my felling on the Apparition clear:)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Herapa

Herapa

Active Member
Donor
Sep 10, 2017
880
685
MOM? I never thought she was suspicious "she an angle:angel::heartcoveredeyes:".
As for suspicion of the rest
Aunt is smart and knows that there is power at work but I don't know how much she knows?
Marcus is a possibility but I think hes loyal to the MC.
Tracy knows more than she lets on but I think she think she protecting the family.
Alice is innocent as you could be.
Latisha defiantly a no.
Abigail I think is innocent and naive but something make me think she to know more than she lets on.
Knew chick I don't trust but I need more context.
I think I've made my felling on the Apparition clear:)
The thing that bugs me about mom is that she appears in aunt's dreams... she doesn't appear in anyone others' dreams... just the aunt. About aunt I suspect that her husband is from the Order and had manipulated her with the spell (that explains her thoughts about the strange feelings she's experiencing around MC, after we told her to be more nice... etc. And that's why she didn't go with mom at the yoga studio. Then again... what if it is not the husband, but mom who is using the spell on her... maybe even as a child? And that's why she stays away from her... Damn so many options... so many unknowns... GIVE US THE NEW RELEASE ALREADY... WITH ANSWERS.. NOT QUESTIONS :D). Marcus knows too much thanks to MC and has always other business to attend to and that makes him suspicious. Tracy I believe is manipulated by the new woman but I think they fight the Order, not helping them (speculation).
 

John The Boogeyman Wick

Active Member
Jul 12, 2017
618
690
The thing that bugs me about mom is that she appears in aunt's dreams... she doesn't appear in anyone others' dreams... just the aunt. About aunt I suspect that her husband is from the Order and had manipulated her with the spell (that explains her thoughts about the strange feelings she's experiencing around MC, after we told her to be more nice... etc. And that's why she didn't go with mom at the yoga studio. Then again... what if it is not the husband, but mom who is using the spell on her... maybe even as a child? And that's why she stays away from her... Damn so many options... so many unknowns... GIVE US THE NEW RELEASE ALREADY... WITH ANSWERS.. NOT QUESTIONS :D). Marcus knows too much thanks to MC and has always other business to attend to and that makes him suspicious. Tracy I believe is manipulated by the new woman but I think they fight the Order, not helping them (speculation).
I think the aunt says she trust her sister and is a little jealous of her or something to that effect "It's right after the sex scene". The Apparition are using mom's image to break the Aunt's will because she trust her sister and maybe sexually attracted to her. Let's be honest, I think lewlab knows we wanted to see them "have some sister time, together;)" and that's why she's in the dream.

In my opinion, I don't think the aunt is being manipulated she supposed to have strong will that's why it's hard get answers from her. I agree with you on Tracy. But I guess we will have to just wait and see.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: dbp5ca and Herapa

Herapa

Active Member
Donor
Sep 10, 2017
880
685
I think the aunt says she trust her sister and is a little jealous of her or something to that effect "It's right after the sex scene". The Apparition are using mom's image to break the Aunt's will because she trust her sister and maybe sexually attracted to her. Let's be honest I think lewlab knows we wanted to see them "have some sister time, together;)" and that's why she's in the dream.

In my opinion I don't think the aunt is being manipulated she supposed to have strong will that's why it's hard get answers from her. I agree with you on Tracy. But I guess we will have to just wait and see.
Yeah, makes sense... but as I said... this game makes me question every NPC (nothing bad about it :D). Despite all, after the sex between MC and aunt, she opened up towards MC and I believe she was sincier about the things she said and she was friendlier than ever. I believe her "strong will" is made by the Spell used on her (maybe her husband, maybe someone else) but after MC broke her "strong will" (and sex night) she was feeling relieved and easy going... dang it.. she was even NICE to the MC, so I think she's a friend :D
 

wep

OffLine
Respected User
Former Staff
Aug 16, 2016
2,899
16,994
On the top I quite sure that the original plan was to use the apparition for the sex scenes in the dreams (like in the first episodes). SO probably we can really judge the presence of Mom in the dreams.
 

Freki

Well-Known Member
Game Developer
May 16, 2017
1,576
1,219
The thing that bugs me about mom is that she appears in aunt's dreams... she doesn't appear in anyone others' dreams... just the aunt. About aunt I suspect that her husband is from the Order and had manipulated her with the spell (that explains her thoughts about the strange feelings she's experiencing around MC, after we told her to be more nice... etc. And that's why she didn't go with mom at the yoga studio. Then again... what if it is not the husband, but mom who is using the spell on her... maybe even as a child? And that's why she stays away from her... Damn so many options... so many unknowns... GIVE US THE NEW RELEASE ALREADY... WITH ANSWERS.. NOT QUESTIONS :D). Marcus knows too much thanks to MC and has always other business to attend to and that makes him suspicious. Tracy I believe is manipulated by the new woman but I think they fight the Order, not helping them (speculation).
only one problem with the idea that her aunt's husband is with the order and used the spell, it's said in the book that the order knows nothing of the spell, just the dream world as only dream walkers can use the spell and they don't have a dream walker.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Herapa

Masturbatey

Newbie
Sep 14, 2016
15
100
My theories so far, Sorry if its a bit long :coldsweat:

  1. "How did the order find out about us having powers?"
    *(Think about it this way) Have we heard anything about Marcus and Mc's past how they became friends anything?*

    The first time(s) we see the order tailing us its when Marcus is with us (in the coffee shop and outside walking around). It has something to do with Marcus I think he's working for them.

  2. "Marcus is our boy (why would he work for them/why would he do something like that/how could he?)"
    *(Think about it this way) why did sin write in that you have to tell him you have powers, Yeah you get to chose how much info you want to give him but either way he still finds out that you have these powers no matter what. It's so there isn't a plot hole in the story. That's also why he whats you to prove that you have them during his party.*

    It could even be that Helen was working for or even possibly leading the order all those years ago and she just fucked over the prophet so that she could steal a dream shard from him, Which gave her slight powers that the order have still been using to this day.

  3. "What does that have to do with Marcus?"

    The order used those powers on you while you slept planting memory's in your head that Marcus is your friend when in reality hes just an agent on the inside informing the order if you in fact have powers or not.

    Or it could just be that he is actually Mc's friend and that the order kidnapped his sister and are black mailing him into helping them get what they want.

    It could even be that Marcus signaled the guy at the coffee shop when you mentioned powers that's why the guy looked at you two.

  4. "How/Why did they know you had these powers in the first place?"
    *(Think about it this way) It's in your blood*

    It could be that one of your parents are a decedent of the the prophet or even a decedent of the prophet and Helen!

  5. "But why chose to investigate you first?"

    They didn't.

    This could explain why Tracy has been acting mysterious they investigated her to see if she had powers first and they thought they wiped her memory's when actually she still remembers and she's trying to protect the family.

    Or maybe they didn't even check her first maybe she was second and Mc's dad was the first that they investigated but for some reason they didn't let him go (Maybe he had a little bit of power and they still need him for those powers to get closer to you?).


  6. "But why did the order do all this since you said they already have a dream shard(s)?"
    *(Think about it this way) Maybe the order is planing something and they don't have enough power.*


    They need to farm dream shards!

    They need to get control of the Apparition so that they could use him as a direct supplier for dream shards!

  7. "Any thing else?"

    I had a few more ideas like the aunt the new lady at the end of 7 Abigail Helen and the Dad/Mom Could all be related like Helen is the grate grate grate grandma, the new lady, the aunt, Mom or Dad are all siblings and Abigail is the new lady's daughter.

    And maybe that's how they got to Tracy was to use Abigail like Marcus.

    Also maybe since the order has some dream powers their giving us those nightmares making it seem like a side effect to scare us off from wanting to keep using powers like maybe their gonna try to persuade us to let them help by saying "oh you can trust us" "we're not bad" "we're here to help you control the power" "we'll help you get rid of the nightmares" "as long as you help us :evilsmile:" or some shit like that.

    I also had one where I thought Marcus was/could be the Apparition. :biggrin:

    Its just none of these made enough sense (to many holes in the story).
PS. I haven't look at all the other theories posted here so sorry if I said something some one else has also said (Something about like minds or how ever it goes ;)).
 
Last edited:
4.20 star(s) 295 Votes