I own the game. one of my favorites to be honest. I dont remember if the scene is removed or not, but it wasnt the whinning. it was that the dev was called out for adding a ntr scene that made absolutely zero sense.
Yeah, it was an absolutely retarded scene which didn't make much sense at all. Also easy to avoid because you just needed to say 'no', or get the guy killed...i did both, first because it's obvious you don't bet your sister for sex, second i wanted the guy dead, the killing scene was fun.
Don't know about if he made it as fan service...iirc, the scene wasn't animated and was only a couple of renders, but there was a huge shit storm, which was how i even found out that there is such a scene...
The difference is that Caribdis learned his lesson and there was no more controversial content in his games and both of his games were quite successful.
His games are just overal better, be it story, writing or visuals and he's way better at writing romance.
That being said, the cheating scene alone i don't see as controversial, if he doesn't add any cuck crap with the LI's i have no problem.
If she was a LI, or the MC acted like a voyeur or cuck i'd certainly agree on that and be pissed.
I know, my point was that she still remained a nympho whore, even after he removed the ntr and her retarded backstory, in the end she was a whore for no reason even after the retcon. Thats whats going to happen with Roxy here, people expecting her sluttiness to be a red herring will just be disappointed.
He only remade the rape backstory of Elaine, but Elaine was an easy hoe which gets around long before that scene. Pretty obviously at that, from the very first time you meet her and she remaind just that, she had no character or relationship development, she was basically still the easy slut in a fwb relation with the MC until the ending choice rolled in...man it pissed me off that you needed her and her web cam friend to get the harem end...
He would have had to rewrite her entire story/character to change that and she didn't have any story or plot beside the easy slut for sex scenes...add to that, Elaines backstory came pretty late in the game, at that point i'd have been likely be easier if he hade just removed her character, wouldn't have lost much, she was barely present in the later part of the story anyway.
I do hope Roxy gets a better story and is not the easy slut she seems to be, but yeah, i won't hold my breath...frankly i find this way worse than this dumb cheating scene, i just hate slut LI's, especially in a harem game and even worse if she's the best looking one among them, again...
