damnedfrog
Engaged Member
- Nov 11, 2020
- 2,231
- 4,647
- 378
OK, my theory.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
Dude when tf is it going to erupt? I'm tired of getting blue balled.
RonaldGrand6969
Well-Known Member
- Aug 30, 2019
- 1,001
- 4,477
- 408
In all Honesty, this is an Incredible Theory.
We know Ashe has been going through some Mental Health issues, and gets especially Crazy when it comes to Sexual Shit. All of the Blackmailing started RIGHT AFTER her First Time, maybe something got fucked in her head after that? It would explain Why all the Requests are Sexual. Also, the Devil in her Head, the Devil Version of herself so to speak, eerily speaks JUST like the Blackmailer, being Manipulative and Unforgiving of her Actions or Hesitation, even going so far as to say "Duplo Spawn", which is a WILD level of Belittling/Sexism. Hell, the Blackmailing only seems to Trigger when she's Alone too, save for the Date with Vanessa, when the Vibrator goes off, but even then, Ashe Steps out to take the Text, this leaving herself alone with her Thoughts.
I can't remember, but is there an Actual Time Ashe SHOWS the Texts to anyone? I know her Boss Receives a Text showing her Picture, but it's I can't remember if it was Explicitly Said that it was Sent from an Unknown Number. I just remember her Mentioning it to her Sister Rachael, and...that's about it. Of course all of this would probably be Debunkable if Ashe showed someone, buuuut again, I can't remember, and where's the fun in going back to check and make this Whole Theory obsolete?
Anyway, the Reason could be Guilt? Whatever happened with her Mom, Ashe clearly still gets Nightmares, and it seems like her Inner Psyche/Devil always tried to Belittle or Accuse her of not being Enough, or Chooses to Punish her Verbally. If Blackmailing is a Completely made up Mass-Hallucination on Ashe's part, that would explain how the Blackmailer:
-Knows All of her Contacts
-Knew that she Didn't Fuck Vanessa
-Knew that she even Kissed her in the first place
But, it wouldn't Explain, and would even be Contradictory that the Blackmailer wouldn't know that Ashe:
-Didn't send a Legit Nude
-Didn't Put in the Buttplug
Still, the Levels of Fucked your Mind under Distress can put you through, you'd be surprised. Especially if Ashe is just keeping it all Bottled up, and any other Outside Sources that prove too Stimulating (Virginity Loss, her Sister Returning, Vanessa Dating/Parent Meeting, Natasha Police Harassment, Drug Dealing, Drug Taking, etc.) suddenly pop up whilst you're already not in a Good Headspace. An Eruption would Certainly be Imminent under this kind of Mental Pressure.
nln0
Well-Known Member
- Sep 4, 2017
- 1,905
- 1,875
- 394
NO.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
sparticus42
Member
- Feb 14, 2025
- 118
- 196
- 52
This is pretty solid theorycrafting. 'The Other One' is literally just Ashe reskinned with devil horns and such. And we know from some of Ashe's inner monologue that at least a small part of her blames herself for what happened to her mother and that she has a lot of emotional trauma tied up in whatever happened to Jane.
My only issue is that this would likely lead the story down a much darker path than it seems Morri is writing as of now. Otherwise there's as much meat to this theory as there are to most of the others I've seen.
Birdnman993
Well-Known Member
- Dec 6, 2021
- 1,903
- 3,172
- 397
I wonder how far the blackmail will go. I'm curious to see if she'll force Ashe into prostitution or make her run naked through the city. The sky's the limit, and she can make her do anything.
I highly doubt that Rachel is the blackmailer, but I find the idea interesting, as it gives her a significant advantage in controlling what Ashe does and keeping an eye on her, no matter what she does. Besides, Ashe would never suspect her. But again, I highly doubt that it is.
I highly doubt that Rachel is the blackmailer, but I find the idea interesting, as it gives her a significant advantage in controlling what Ashe does and keeping an eye on her, no matter what she does. Besides, Ashe would never suspect her. But again, I highly doubt that it is.
Kontralta
Active Member
- Sep 28, 2023
- 779
- 1,119
- 267
It's like Call of Duty Black Ops. I like it.
Buletti
Engaged Member
- Nov 7, 2023
- 2,058
- 3,485
- 349
Buletti
Engaged Member
- Nov 7, 2023
- 2,058
- 3,485
- 349
I think when she is talking to Rachel she also shows her phone and they both look at the text on the Screen.
Stompai
Member
- Oct 7, 2017
- 498
- 2,002
- 414
I think that when she was in the gym to take a selfie, we get to see a 3rd person view of the phone screen as she is chatting with the unknown number while in her udnerwear and get to see the messages appearing directly. Don't remember if we see both her arms but one almost certain, so unless her double personality work like a light switch and she hides the second phone in her pantie...
Kontralta
Active Member
- Sep 28, 2023
- 779
- 1,119
- 267
No, Ashe didn't show the messages to anyone, she only told Rachel about it.
Kontralta
Active Member
- Sep 28, 2023
- 779
- 1,119
- 267
The point is not that she sends messages to herself, but that she imagines it.
Kontralta
Active Member
- Sep 28, 2023
- 779
- 1,119
- 267
Stompai
Member
- Oct 7, 2017
- 498
- 2,002
- 414
Oh, my bad, thought it was the only possible way to see it since she is sleeping when she receives the first messages and the camera pointing to the phone showing the notifications was definitely for the player himself who know about the blackmail before even the mc herself, not from Ashe's perspective.
Kontralta
Active Member
- Sep 28, 2023
- 779
- 1,119
- 267
It could just be a cool cliffhanger. A pretty compelling argument for hallucinations is that she didn't show the messages to anyone, including Rachel.
Lurcher1
Member
- Sep 20, 2022
- 386
- 1,142
- 226
Ok, de-lurking to comment on this amazing theory-craft. Her darker half also feeds into the comments Fiona makes about Duplo's being descended from daemons or words to that effect. That could feed into this idea, that the daemonic part of herself is fueling her mental distress and making her think she's being blackmailed.
sparticus42
Member
- Feb 14, 2025
- 118
- 196
- 52
Yeah, I thought it was mostly a joke at first, but the more I consider it, it holds as much weight as most of the other theories we've seen proposed. Would make for some interesting storytelling.
Jafo
Well-Known Member
- Oct 8, 2017
- 1,322
- 4,379
- 445
|