Buletti

Engaged Member
Nov 7, 2023
2,427
4,448
400
My guess is that it should be someone random and unimportant like Siri, and because she does it, we shouldn't give it too much importance either. Just say she's a religious fanatic and that's it.
To be honest, that would not do any justice to the buildup and the importance this arc has for Ashe and for the audience. I don't think a writer like Morrigan would go a cheap way like this.

With all the arguments about Evelyn it could be together with Deli and maybe even Fiona (working in a phone store and being the closest friend and least suspicious).

It is just mindboggling, how good all these clues are and that Morrigan is still able to fuck with us this much.
 

Pinnedyr

Member
Jun 16, 2025
126
149
77
To be honest, that would not do any justice to the buildup and the importance this arc has for Ashe and for the audience. I don't think a writer like Morrigan would go a cheap way like this.

With all the arguments about Evelyn it could be together with Deli and maybe even Fiona (working in a phone store and being the closest friend and least suspicious).

It is just mindboggling, how good all these clues are and that Morrigan is still able to fuck with us this much.
i dont know what the heck to belive anymore i put them all on list just to be certain :KEK: :ROFLMAO: :cry: but what you are saying right now does actualy make sense it could be multiple people we know working together to build this smooth blackmailer machine..
 
  • Like
Reactions: Buletti

xeivous

Member
Mar 16, 2018
388
314
257
I'm pretty sure the blackmailer is either somehow connected to Vanessa's mom or the duplo influencer who ended up on the news after killing herself. Though how connected to Ashe they otherwise are is really up for grabs as I'm pretty sure the strongest evidence we got was for Delilah and she turned out to be probably a red herring.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sdibolcrif
Mar 8, 2023
67
51
28
There's no way the blackmailer could be the mother or sister, they'd have to convincingly portray the characters as complete sociopaths. I believe it will be someone with a some kind of obssesion with MC, perhaps a character who hasn't appeared yet and is close to someone at the party.
So...for all we know, Oriana?
 

Chillout1984

Conversation Conqueror
Nov 15, 2020
6,447
5,218
634
So...for all we know, Oriana?
Oriana didn't give me the impression she is obsessed with Ashe. Imo as far as we can see Bella, Brianna and Delilah and maybe the camera girl (forgot her name) are the only girls that have an obsession with MC on every path. So if obsession is the main reason, it would most likely be one of them. However I think those chances are minimal and if it is indeed one of them, either Delilah or the camera girl seem to be the most likely suspects for me.
 

Hsjsjjsjsj

Newbie
Oct 13, 2020
57
92
112
Oriana didn't give me the impression she is obsessed with Ashe. Imo as far as we can see Bella, Brianna and Delilah and maybe the camera girl (forgot her name) are the only girls that have an obsession with MC on every path. So if obsession is the main reason, it would most likely be one of them. However I think those chances are minimal and if it is indeed one of them, either Delilah or the camera girl seem to be the most likely suspects for me.
Of those, Bella certainly wouldn't do that. Her personality is more that someone who bully the person she likes, but wouldn't go to that extreme given how she reacted for MC being duplo.
 

Omniel

Member
Donor
Jun 28, 2017
371
593
362
To be honest, that would not do any justice to the buildup and the importance this arc has for Ashe and for the audience. I don't think a writer like Morrigan would go a cheap way like this.

With all the arguments about Evelyn it could be together with Deli and maybe even Fiona (working in a phone store and being the closest friend and least suspicious).

It is just mindboggling, how good all these clues are and that Morrigan is still able to fuck with us this much.
I don't believe it's either Evelyn or Rachel. I still suspect Delilah, and as you mentioned it could also be Fiona or possibly both together. It's just a gut feeling I have.
 

Kontralta

Active Member
Sep 28, 2023
855
1,294
267
I'm starting to think Morrigan hasn't yet decided who the blackmailer is and is just watching the players' reactions. This is proven by the fact that as soon as the players, for some unknown reason, started to suspect Delilah, Morrigan trolled them and then destroyed their hypothesis. There are literally no hints at all about who the blackmailer really is.
 

Pinnedyr

Member
Jun 16, 2025
126
149
77
I'm starting to think Morrigan hasn't yet decided who the blackmailer is and is just watching the players' reactions. This is proven by the fact that as soon as the players, for some unknown reason, started to suspect Delilah, Morrigan trolled them and then destroyed their hypothesis. There are literally no hints at all about who the blackmailer really is.
If thats the case thats close to Pure evil. making the loyal Fans having sleepless nights over this its seriously bothering me haha. i most of all as im on siren path want to tear that blackmailer a new asshole and make them regret their life decisions.
 

AVNLoverGirl

New Member
Oct 1, 2025
9
21
64
I don't think Oriana is the blackmailer because if anything she seems amused to run into Ashe. There were numerous glances which made me think while playing that she was still interested in Ashe, before the reveal she's one of the 10 LIs. Mostly though, was one scene that seemed to have been noticed by most people, but that most seem to have missed the greater implications of.

No, it was me who asked if there was anything preventing Oriana from being Ms. X. She thought Ashe ghosted her, which can cause some crazy behaviour in hot girls who are not used to that.
The key part of that scene isn't that she thought Ashe ghosted her, she said Ashe blocked her. The only way a dating website would give you a message that would make you think that is if you tried to communicate with someone after that. So, my guess is she was interested and wanted to give Ashe another chance, but when she got a message saying user not available she thought she was blocked. That was why I was not at all surprised to see her on the list of LIs.

Also, there have been numerous messages about Delilah and her sneaking around, which is how she says she found out about Ashe. I believe it, because twice before Fiona had called her sneaky and said she liked to get into things she shouldn't. She also showed herself willing to let herself into Fiona's room while Ashe was there.

I used to think it was Kate's wife, but I am leaning towards 3 other alternatives now.

1. Marita - Ashe's boss who is said to be very religious. Not very likely however.
2. The lady who lives next door to Natasha, who is also the reporter who read the story on Sunny's death. Again, not likely, unless she was involved in the hacking thing. However, I DO think she's Delilah's new employer, who she spilled coffee on.
3. The most likely one, to my mind, is Jessica (Moira's partner). She has Means (as she has access to at least some of Moira's resources), Motive (Both getting revenge on Vanessa for her being so hateful to her, and to get back at Ashe for being part of the whole fiasco at The Pearl), and Opportunity (No one knows what the fuck she does, since she clearly doesn't use any of her time working). It might also explain a bit of Vanessa's reaction.

Personally, I think her reaction was due to one of 3 people in her life being a duplo. Moira, Jessica, or her other mother. I have read the theory here that her other mother was a duplo, and the libido suppressant drugs, which Evelyn states have bad side effects, could have caused her cancer and so it freaked her out that she was getting close to another duplo. Possible, but not likely IMO. Second, Moira, which would explain her anger. If she had pinned her infidelity on her being a duplo, I could see it. Probable, but I think Jessica is a better option.

It would explain the almost instinctive rage and hate that spewed from her, even shocking Bella. If she thought that the reason Moira cheated on her other mother was because Jessica is a duplo, then she might have based a lot of her hate and vitriol towards her on that fact, and Ashe was collateral damage, which would make an eventual apology acceptable. So, I think that she is the most likely, not only because it would give a target that most of us could accept, but it would drive a wedge between Moira and Jessica, and possibly help Moira patch up her relationship with her daughter some. That's just my thoughts on the matter though.

now that i think of it . did she mention where the work trip was at?
Port Opal, which is far enough away that she has to take a plane to get there.
 

Pinnedyr

Member
Jun 16, 2025
126
149
77
I don't think Oriana is the blackmailer because if anything she seems amused to run into Ashe. There were numerous glances which made me think while playing that she was still interested in Ashe, before the reveal she's one of the 10 LIs. Mostly though, was one scene that seemed to have been noticed by most people, but that most seem to have missed the greater implications of.



The key part of that scene isn't that she thought Ashe ghosted her, she said Ashe blocked her. The only way a dating website would give you a message that would make you think that is if you tried to communicate with someone after that. So, my guess is she was interested and wanted to give Ashe another chance, but when she got a message saying user not available she thought she was blocked. That was why I was not at all surprised to see her on the list of LIs.

Also, there have been numerous messages about Delilah and her sneaking around, which is how she says she found out about Ashe. I believe it, because twice before Fiona had called her sneaky and said she liked to get into things she shouldn't. She also showed herself willing to let herself into Fiona's room while Ashe was there.

I used to think it was Kate's wife, but I am leaning towards 3 other alternatives now.

1. Marita - Ashe's boss who is said to be very religious. Not very likely however.
2. The lady who lives next door to Natasha, who is also the reporter who read the story on Sunny's death. Again, not likely, unless she was involved in the hacking thing. However, I DO think she's Delilah's new employer, who she spilled coffee on.
3. The most likely one, to my mind, is Jessica (Moira's partner). She has Means (as she has access to at least some of Moira's resources), Motive (Both getting revenge on Vanessa for her being so hateful to her, and to get back at Ashe for being part of the whole fiasco at The Pearl), and Opportunity (No one knows what the fuck she does, since she clearly doesn't use any of her time working). It might also explain a bit of Vanessa's reaction.

Personally, I think her reaction was due to one of 3 people in her life being a duplo. Moira, Jessica, or her other mother. I have read the theory here that her other mother was a duplo, and the libido suppressant drugs, which Evelyn states have bad side effects, could have caused her cancer and so it freaked her out that she was getting close to another duplo. Possible, but not likely IMO. Second, Moira, which would explain her anger. If she had pinned her infidelity on her being a duplo, I could see it. Probable, but I think Jessica is a better option.

It would explain the almost instinctive rage and hate that spewed from her, even shocking Bella. If she thought that the reason Moira cheated on her other mother was because Jessica is a duplo, then she might have based a lot of her hate and vitriol towards her on that fact, and Ashe was collateral damage, which would make an eventual apology acceptable. So, I think that she is the most likely, not only because it would give a target that most of us could accept, but it would drive a wedge between Moira and Jessica, and possibly help Moira patch up her relationship with her daughter some. That's just my thoughts on the matter though.



Port Opal, which is far enough away that she has to take a plane to get there.
i will NEVER Forgive Vanessa for me personaly she can go Fk herself i dont care what kind of personal Problems she has that Reaction and hatefullness is UNFORGIVEABLE in my Book and in front of a Crowd makes me even more pissed off.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Birdnman993

Kontralta

Active Member
Sep 28, 2023
855
1,294
267
1. Marita - Ashe's boss who is said to be very religious. Not very likely however.
2. The lady who lives next door to Natasha, who is also the reporter who read the story on Sunny's death. Again, not likely, unless she was involved in the hacking thing. However, I DO think she's Delilah's new employer, who she spilled coffee on.
3. The most likely one, to my mind, is Jessica (Moira's partner). She has Means (as she has access to at least some of Moira's resources), Motive (Both getting revenge on Vanessa for her being so hateful to her, and to get back at Ashe for being part of the whole fiasco at The Pearl), and Opportunity (No one knows what the fuck she does, since she clearly doesn't use any of her time working). It might also explain a bit of Vanessa's reaction.
1. Religiosity explains the hatred of the duplo, but a religious person won't give you a task to send a photo in your underwear or to have sex with someone. Or maybe I don't understand religious people.
2. This is too far-fetched. We know absolutely nothing about her.
3. Jessica simply doesn't have the brains for that.
 
Last edited:

AVNLoverGirl

New Member
Oct 1, 2025
9
21
64
1. Religiosity explains the hatred of the duplo, but a religious person won't give you a task to send a photo in your underwear or to have sex with someone. Or maybe I don't understand religious people.
2. This is too far-fetched. We know absolutely nothing about her.
3. Jessica simply doesn't have the brains for that.
I pointed out that the first two weren't likely. As for Jessica, lack of intelligence doesn't negate craftiness and downright sneakiness. Don't discount her so quickly because she's dumb. After all, she might have been playing dumber than she is.
 

Kontralta

Active Member
Sep 28, 2023
855
1,294
267
I pointed out that the first two weren't likely. As for Jessica, lack of intelligence doesn't negate craftiness and downright sneakiness. Don't discount her so quickly because she's dumb. After all, she might have been playing dumber than she is.
To pull this off would require intelligence, which Jessica clearly doesn't have. I doubt she was playing dumb; why would she do that?
 
4.80 star(s) 155 Votes