Dorfnutter
Engaged Member
- May 21, 2017
- 3,914
- 23,260
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
- Thread starter Caribdis
- Start date
I dont claim it. It is my opinion. Thats why I said "IMO" (in my opinion). Because Penny is currently the least developed character, she does not really have anything going for her except for being a somewhat popular model and having big boobs. The other LIs are currently more fleshed out, even if some of them did not really have much content. (E.g. Lunas character is more unique than Pennys, even if Luna also did not have that much content yet)
Obviously, on their own, every LI is good. They are likeable characters. But if you compare them, you will see the difference. And this is why some people have a favorite and others have a different favorite.
rudy007
Engaged Member
- Mar 17, 2021
- 2,542
- 6,467
You're right... But when anyone see Penny the first time, nobody would say that she's underdeveloped...
This is the part I took issue with. You cannot make that inference from the poll.
Takkatakka
Engaged Member
- Nov 11, 2022
- 3,243
- 11,131
I mean no one should take that poll to serious and in the end the answer with by far the most votes was "harem" anyway, as it should be.
The truth is that I feel both Dalia and especially Penny simply hadn't much time to shine so far. Dalia had her competition which was nice, but not too special and Penny had that touching memory and the Halloween party where she was gone for a long time, so we could've awesome and funny scenes with Nova instead. Penny got mostly outshined in what originally seemed like it would be mainly her scene.
Both lack a niche they can call their own, in my opinion. Yes, Dalia is the sporty one but that only really shows with her having slightly more defined abs than any of the other girls. Her big conflict is that she is only the 2nd best woman in sports in the city...damn, what a serious problem to have...
Penny on the other hand is supposed to look a bit more like a blonde bimbo but is actually pretty smart. But that only comes through here and there and in the big boob department her mother is right there with her anyway, also bringing the red hair and the potential milf appeal into the mix. Her internal problem is that her good looks kinda outshine her intelligence and that people are very superficial in regards to her. And again: "I'm looking too good!" is another serious problem, a lot of people can very much relate to...
So ultimately it isn't too much of a surprise to me that those two are probably the least favorite LIs in the game so far, because they both are comparatively boring to begin with AND they haven't been to fleshed out either. At least as of now neither of the two really had stand out scenes as far as I remember, with the exception of Penny's memory I would say.
And no, I don't think either of them is unpopular that would mean that people actively don't like them and rather would them see gone from the story. I think that most players don't care as much about the two as they do about the others like Luna, Alex, Annie or Nova mainly.
- Nov 21, 2022
- 1,246
- 6,228
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
- Aug 30, 2017
- 1,588
- 4,296
Ungawa
Well-Known Member
- Apr 16, 2017
- 1,607
- 6,007
Just adding to this, but with Penny, Nova takes most of the spotlight in the party. You're at a college party and who just got dunked on? Penny. Who's there to help with everything? Nova.I mean no one should take that poll to serious and in the end the answer with by far the most votes was "harem" anyway, as it should be.
The truth is that I feel both Dalia and especially Penny simply hadn't much time to shine so far. Dalia had her competition which was nice, but not too special and Penny had that touching memory and the Halloween party where she was gone for a long time, so we could've awesome and funny scenes with Nova instead. Penny got mostly outshined in what originally seemed like it would be mainly her scene.
Both lack a niche they can call their own, in my opinion. Yes, Dalia is the sporty one but that only really shows with her having slightly more defined abs than any of the other girls. Her big conflict is that she is only the 2nd best woman in sports in the city...damn, what a serious problem to have...
Penny on the other hand is supposed to look a bit more like a blonde bimbo but is actually pretty smart. But that only comes through here and there and in the big boob department her mother is right there with her anyway, also bringing the red hair and the potential milf appeal into the mix. Her internal problem is that her good looks kinda outshine her intelligence and that people are very superficial in regards to her. And again: "I'm looking too good!" is another serious problem, a lot of people can very much relate to...
So ultimately it isn't too much of a surprise to me that those two are probably the least favorite LIs in the game so far, because they both are comparatively boring to begin with AND they haven't been to fleshed out either. At least as of now neither of the two really had stand out scenes as far as I remember, with the exception of Penny's memory I would say.
And no, I don't think either of them is unpopular that would mean that people actively don't like them and rather would them see gone from the story. I think that most players don't care as much about the two as they do about the others like Luna, Alex, Annie or Nova mainly.
You wonder why the C. O. N. is a thing but you've had more screentime with Nova than you've had with almost any of the Carters and that's saying something.
For Dalia, Alex has the screen time and the Ice Queen presence to really move her out the way. Sure, Dalia is a gym rat while Penny is a social celebrity. But that doesn't make them unique or enticing. I like them as characters, but as LIs they're really side characters since Nova is closer to Orion for longer just the same as Alex is.
e6mill
Engaged Member
- Aug 4, 2022
- 3,340
- 6,621
Nova's alias was mentioned to us by Idriel on our very first visit. Any of the Carters posess a weapon of Atlas?
Dorfnutter
Engaged Member
- May 21, 2017
- 3,914
- 23,260
You know what would be crazy?
I know she was probably a one and done character but I hope we'll see her again.
If Eva and Maat get upgraded to main LIs in Cari's 3rd game.
Imagine the thread war though?
"NTR'd by Orion!? Carib betrayed us!"
Yeah. That'd be a real hoot.
"NTR'd by Orion!? Carib betrayed us!"
Yeah. That'd be a real hoot.
Dorfnutter
Engaged Member
- May 21, 2017
- 3,914
- 23,260
I mean if a timeskip is involved again then they could end up as the MILFs of the harem.Imagine the thread war though?
"NTR'd by Orion!? Carib betrayed us!"
Yeah. That'd be a real hoot.
Also Orion banged them while they're strapped in Eternum so not sure if that even counts lol.
It wouldn't to me, but then...
"A t-shirt the L.I. is wearing was made by a man - NTR!" people exist.
It’s hilarious to me that you list out all these reasons that are negative against Dalia and Penny. Then at the end add in Annie, like she isn’t the most cliche out of all of them as the shy virgin neighbor girl who was secretly in love. Her problem is “We’re good friends so I’m afraid to act on romance and ruin it”. In your words such a serious problem.I mean no one should take that poll to serious and in the end the answer with by far the most votes was "harem" anyway, as it should be.
The truth is that I feel both Dalia and especially Penny simply hadn't much time to shine so far. Dalia had her competition which was nice, but not too special and Penny had that touching memory and the Halloween party where she was gone for a long time, so we could've awesome and funny scenes with Nova instead. Penny got mostly outshined in what originally seemed like it would be mainly her scene.
Both lack a niche they can call their own, in my opinion. Yes, Dalia is the sporty one but that only really shows with her having slightly more defined abs than any of the other girls. Her big conflict is that she is only the 2nd best woman in sports in the city...damn, what a serious problem to have...
Penny on the other hand is supposed to look a bit more like a blonde bimbo but is actually pretty smart. But that only comes through here and there and in the big boob department her mother is right there with her anyway, also bringing the red hair and the potential milf appeal into the mix. Her internal problem is that her good looks kinda outshine her intelligence and that people are very superficial in regards to her. And again: "I'm looking too good!" is another serious problem, a lot of people can very much relate to...
So ultimately it isn't too much of a surprise to me that those two are probably the least favorite LIs in the game so far, because they both are comparatively boring to begin with AND they haven't been to fleshed out either. At least as of now neither of the two really had stand out scenes as far as I remember, with the exception of Penny's memory I would say.
And no, I don't think either of them is unpopular that would mean that people actively don't like them and rather would them see gone from the story. I think that most players don't care as much about the two as they do about the others like Luna, Alex, Annie or Nova mainly.
I think all of the characters are great but in hierarchy she is by far the least interesting in my personal opinion.
Ungawa
Well-Known Member
- Apr 16, 2017
- 1,607
- 6,007
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
For all intents and purposes, Annie should be MUCH, MUCH farther down the path than she is, especially with the alone time and trauma of the Andromeda server. The story isn't playing to her strengths at all and what was established since jump.
She's a powerful mage, she's played Eternum longer than Orion, but she's constantly in the worst roles that she's at a significant disadvantage. No magic. Can't stand horror. And constantly self conscious which vagblocks her something fierce.
I truly wish that Cari had combined them into a unique character that was a gym rat, social media with presence, because personally, I feel he did Annie the dirtiest out of them all, Dalia is closer on the personal path, and Penny just seems to constantly be on the backburner even though she's the tits.
The previews of 0.7 seem to do well to give her (Penny) something so I'm just hoping Dalia and Annie are done far better in the next update and 0.8.
Takkatakka
Engaged Member
- Nov 11, 2022
- 3,243
- 11,131
Well, you're kinda answering your own question there: Annie is the shy and cute girl next door. And while you might not like that niche, she obviously works well enough for a lot of others. Also she had some very cool and funny moments, especially in the last patch.
And yes, her problem is somewhat cliched, but at the very least it revolves around the MC and therefore the player. The player can interact with it and get engaged with her problem directly.
And sure, for you she might be the least interesting. That is very fair and there are also some that like Dalia or Penny the most out of all the LIs. But in general Dalia and Penny seem to be the least appreciated LIs on average which would be supported by the poll.
ChipLecsap
Conversation Conqueror
- Aug 4, 2019
- 7,581
- 27,050
I'm so grateful, that Dorfnutter posted that 2021 bot survey, It is exactly what this threads was needed , great job .
.When 0.7 drops someone should post it again.I'm so grateful, that Dorfnutter posted that 2021 bot survey, It is exactly what this threads was needed , great job
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.