bolenart

Member
Jun 17, 2017
187
433
There are downsides to this very simple voting system. Someone like Calypso could be the second favorite of a lot of people and yet end up in the bottom of first favorites. The ideal system would be everyone putting a 1-5 rating to every girl, and then arranging them after average rating, but that would be manipulated as some people give 1's on the girls they feel are too highly rated (as we see with the game reviews on this site, IMDB ratings etc.). The best system in practice is probably to select your top 3 (or top 5) and give these 3, 2, 1 points respectively and then look at the sums.

With that said, generally I dislike these votes as they just lead to animosity and they overshadow the fact that Caribdis has managed to create a cast of LI's that are all universally beloved. I'm confident that every girl has at least an 80% approval rating among the fans, yet the votes make it seem like people don't care for Calypso, Nancy etc.
 

Mutation8888

Member
Jun 15, 2022
350
509
There are downsides to this very simple voting system. Someone like Calypso could be the second favorite of a lot of people and yet end up in the bottom of first favorites. The ideal system would be everyone putting a 1-5 rating to every girl, and then arranging them after average rating, but that would be manipulated as some people give 1's on the girls they feel are too highly rated (as we see with the game reviews on this site, IMDB ratings etc.). The best system in practice is probably to select your top 3 (or top 5) and give these 3, 2, 1 points respectively and then look at the sums.

With that said, generally I dislike these votes as they just lead to animosity and they overshadow the fact that Caribdis has managed to create a cast of LI's that are all universally beloved. I'm confident that every girl has at least an 80% approval rating among the fans, yet the votes make it seem like people don't care for Calypso, Nancy etc.
Exactly. Voting never made sense for me since all of the LI's have their strengths and weaknesses that make each worthwhile in their own niche. Such voting merely shows the social politics of a few select individuals based on a very narrow idea of what is considered attractive or worthwhile.
 

Radish Cruton

Newbie
Nov 14, 2017
79
273
There are downsides to this very simple voting system. Someone like Calypso could be the second favorite of a lot of people and yet end up in the bottom of first favorites. The ideal system would be everyone putting a 1-5 rating to every girl, and then arranging them after average rating, but that would be manipulated as some people give 1's on the girls they feel are too highly rated (as we see with the game reviews on this site, IMDB ratings etc.). The best system in practice is probably to select your top 3 (or top 5) and give these 3, 2, 1 points respectively and then look at the sums.

With that said, generally I dislike these votes as they just lead to animosity and they overshadow the fact that Caribdis has managed to create a cast of LI's that are all universally beloved. I'm confident that every girl has at least an 80% approval rating among the fans, yet the votes make it seem like people don't care for Calypso, Nancy etc.
Here you go, from Reddit - everyone got to rank the girls in order from first to eighth, then points were assigned based on that ranking - 7 for first place, all the way to 0 for eight place.

If I recall correctly, Dalia is a good example, she’s not a lot of people’s first choice, but she is a lot of people’s second or third choice.
0-8-best-li-community-ranking-results-v0-efapms564lge1.png
0-8-best-li-community-ranking-results-v0-1qzubsg64lge1.png
 
Last edited:

Finuee

Gorehound Gal
Game Developer
Sep 14, 2022
626
3,263
Honestly I voted for Alex over Dalia only because of the new pregnancy angle that gets me going for some reason.
Funny how each of us have our different tastes and opinions. For me, the new pregnancy angle reduces her appeal as favourite character. Strictly talking about me, not meaning to say it or reduces her actual appeal. Just that it might make me change favourites.
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: Unreal434

Unreal434

Member
Sep 23, 2018
143
365
No issue here, Your reproductive instincts are working as intended :BootyTime:
I mean it was shocking (in a good way) to see them go into that direction with Alex of all the girls and not Annie or Luna.
Alex seemed to me as someone that would not even joke about having kids because of her athletic career and muh Bardot family.

I hope it doesn´t stop just at teasing in the future though.:HideThePain:
 

4Zero9Zero

Active Member
Sep 21, 2021
607
1,062
I mean it was shocking (in a good way) to see them go into that direction with Alex of all the girls and not Annie or Luna.
Alex seemed to me as someone that would not even joke about having kids because of her athletic career and muh Bardot family.

I hope it doesn´t stop just at teasing in the future though.:HideThePain:
Orion blasted about 4 gallons into her in Christened Apartment, it would've been a hell of a twist if she wasn't pregnant :KEK:
Penny is probably the next announcement followed by Nova who got it twice in her room and her real body in Eternum

I know what you mean though, Alex never gave off those vibes initially, great to see her defenses were handily broken down :BootyTime:
 

Finuee

Gorehound Gal
Game Developer
Sep 14, 2022
626
3,263
Orion blasted about 4 gallons into her in Christened Apartment, it would've been a hell of a twist if she wasn't pregnant :KEK:
Penny is probably the next announcement followed by Nova who got it twice in her room and her real body in Eternum

I know what you mean though, Alex never gave off those vibes initially, great to see her defenses were handily broken down :BootyTime:
Yeah, well, I kinda liked that she didn't have those vibes. But oh well...
 
  • Like
Reactions: sexypeanut

sexypeanut

Well-Known Member
Jun 30, 2020
1,934
3,090
Orion blasted about 4 gallons into her in Christened Apartment, it would've been a hell of a twist if she wasn't pregnant :KEK:
Penny is probably the next announcement followed by Nova who got it twice in her room and her real body in Eternum

I know what you mean though, Alex never gave off those vibes initially, great to see her defenses were handily broken down :BootyTime:
One could imagine Alex would take pills, since she's quite mature for her age.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Finuee
4.80 star(s) 1,062 Votes