It's not surprise NTR. It's literally not NTR at all.
It is and it isn't. Its at least borderline. There's story context to it later that kind of prevents it from being true ntr, but at the time it happens, it kind of feels like it. Its a pretty inconsequential scene anyway though, as far as I'm concerned, especially since sarah's storyline gets mostly pushed to the wayside until the last few chapters.
It is not borderline. There is no "Weeelll kiiiinda" about it. He's into her yes, but she's not his girlfriend, wife, or lover. She's not on the ground wailing about how much better the dick she's taking is than every other dick she's taken or ever will take and how much more of a man the guy is than the MC. Being disappointed that the girl you like is into someone else or having sex with someone else does not mean you're being NTR'd. If that's what it means to you then that's a you problem not an NTR problem.
I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree on this one. NTR is something that is fundamentally subjective. Something that may seem like nothing to you, may seem like it to someone else. The rules of NTR are not set in stone and are determined on the basis of personal opinion. But my personal definition is: any sexual activity with a male character other than the MC that cannot be opted out of or in some way consented to by the MC. If this game was real life or somehow based in reality, I'd agree with your opinion on the subject, but as this is "Fantasy" Valley and not "Harsh-reality-of-unrequited-love" Valley, I'll have to disagree.
I would say as much as possible? probably not the images where you walk into the one chicks room and she is studying in her underwear, or the scenes where you stare at the housekeepers ass while she is cleaning, things along those lines where its just some chick in her normal clothes but bent forward or something, but pretty much anything sexy or anything with boobs should go in. also, was kind of disappointed that certain early scenes with clio didn't show her doing her thing. little nitpick, just food for thought. either way, seems like a good story, interested to see more. especially Yvette, sasha, and that history teacher. big titty milfs for the win. sarah and heather are also great.
If it is "fundamentally subjective," then there is no point to having the tag at all. Many people want to make the definition so broad as to be meaningless. It's like saying a game needs a violence tag because two characters disagree with each other.
I consider an NTR tag as more of disclaimer that there is content you may find objectionable.
To give a couple examples I really liked the scene where you need to find Morgan's book in her room and then you almost get caught but have the chance to spy on her, and also the part in the bandit camp that you had to search for gold and other items to build a helmet and also get the chance to explore the area and to interact with other characters.
