Idk what it's about with the remastered chapter 1. The old Nikki interaction was better in terms of content, at least including the patch.
tldr; I didn't feel like the Nicki that existed through most of the story, matched the one introduced in Chapter 1.
While I think the new Chapter 1 is a big improvement, I did feel like the new 'first major scene' with Nikki felt like a bit of a gut punch and disappointment. It
really bugged me and actually took me a few days (and replaying the original) to sort out why.
I realised that the old scene gave the MC a
reason to become more of a jaded asshole. He got stupid rich and one of the first things a friend does, someone who he should be able to trust (admittedly a bit less so in the original), is to come to him dishonestly and try and get money from him. Sure, it's because Nikki is basically in an abusive relationship and her BF at the time is an asshole, but it still feels like a betrayal. This event gives the MC (and by extension the Player) essentially four reactions, all of which include
some level of feeling betrayal and/or disappointment.
1: Betrayal - Sure Nikki, here's the money, have a nice life. Goodbye.
2: Sympathy - Shit Nikki, that's rough. but you know you could have just
asked me yeah? Here's the money. I'm giving it to you though, not that asshole BF of yours.
3: Anger - Well if you're going to act like a whore, I'll treat you like one.
4: Hate - (dark path required.)
All four actions can make Nikki leave with some kind of feeling of guilt too, which IMO can add to why she disappeared for months.
Nikki's actions in the original version justified (storywise, not morally or legally) how the MC can treat her, and
why the MC might go down a darker path. Or at least to start looking at other people more critically and perhaps be a bit less naive. Lane's (the lawyer) warning in the Chapter 1 remake, about how the MC's new wealth might change friends and family for the worse would make it hit even harder.
In the remake Chapter 1 Nikki event, the MC ghosts her for a month (bit of a dick move, but kind of understandable with everything going on), and Nikki has no idea the MC has money. She comes to him to get away from the shit she's in, if only for a while. I could easily believe that she wasn't even going to tell him about her BF's latest bullshit and the money owed. As far as she knew, the MC was as broke as her after all.
It feels like if you want to go down a meaner, darker path in the remake, its 100% purely based on the
Players decision purely because they decide "I'll do an asshole play-through this time". It didn't feel like the MC had
any reason to do so, just "whelp, I'm rich so guess I'm an asshole now" or something. It comes out of nowhere. It felt like there was no storyline reasoning or justification behind it. (Yeah, yeah, I know you get a couple of really minor choices earlier, but they really don't feel like they have any weight.)
The new Nikki scene IS well written, and if I'd never played the old version, it wouldn't bug me as much (though I'd still feel like it was a bit...lackluster when it came to justifying the choice). A few other changes* aside, I am still enjoying this game.
Just my 2c mini-rant.
*
it felt like the "I'm nineteen and in college! Honest!" dialogue was laid on way too thick and got old really fast.