Pepper is really cute, just my type but it's been so long that I don't really remember much of her problems or personality.
Aside from Nicki, I don't really have any absolute favourites. It's funny, the first time I played I was all over Gabbi, now - no interest at all. Both Ashe and Brittani have moved up my non-existant list a bit. Risa is annoying and just not very interesting so far, however tragic her situation, but we'll see, I haven't got to her content yet so perhaps I'll change my mind.
This really is one of the best written AVNs out there, with some actual psychological depths to the characters. Who cares about boring long ass porn animations when you get this this?