where you conveniently don't see the other guys, but they're talked about so we know they're also fucking the same LI's...
Uh, no.
Just no.
Some of the older girls/women in GoV have prior experience, obviously (just like some girls in Eternum clearly suggest by their behavior that they have prior experience).
But
not recent, and the idea is that you're literally the only guy in town right now (and it'll stay this way during the entire game).
And although it's only implied for now, the girls wouldn't go with other guys anymore after they became part of the MC's harem.
I guess I'll have to make that more clear over the course of the game.
That one dude from the Lyn scene was from a different town, and won't reappear during the rest of the game (nor will any similar scenes with other guys, that scene will remain a bit of an exception).
The idea of GoV is that there are so few men in that world that some towns simply don't have any most of the time, and those guys that exist rarely bother leaving their own town, unless they're so insufferable they struggle to get enough decent women even in their own town (like that old dude from the Lyn scene).
And those news on the PC are from the bigger GoV world in general, not from that town the game plays in.
Anyway, if the game doesn't feel harem-y enough for you, that's OK.
It's not really meant to be the dating sim / emotions-based kind of harem game.
But what you're suggesting with regard to other guys fucking the same LIs is just flat out not the case in the town GoV plays in.
I can see why some people might go
"but it feels like it could be happening in that kind of world", but as the author I can clearly state,
"yeah, it could, but it isn't happening in that particular town during the game, due to the absence of other guys".
Anyway, I won't argue about tags anymore, if people feel this somehow shouldn't have a harem tag, I don't care.
All I can say is, the LIs in GoV aren't and won't ever be getting fucked by other dudes during GoV, neither explicitly nor implicitly, and the majority of them are virgins until they meet the MC.
There will be more free use by the MC, but nobody else.