Just felt the need to comment on how out of place the good/bad route vs. the relationship with Bernard is starting to feel. Playing through it once again, I'm hitting the point where Bernard talks to Ash about the sex they had, and Ash has a moral crisis. With my Ash being about 90% bad in this playthrough, I managed to get the initial sex scene started, but since my Ash has.. mid forties somewhere bad girl points, and only 13 (so <20) good girl points, I can only respond with outrage and a moral crisis over incest. For reference, good girl Ashley would dive headfirst into this incestuous tryst if you pick that option.
This is the opposite of making sense. I've known plenty of bad and good girls. To the good girls, anal is often a crazy fantasy, a taboo like incest will scare them away. They wouldn't even get past the social pressure behind it to start considering the topic personally.
Conversely, I have yet to meet a bad girl who hasn't already, by herself, at least fantasized about incest just for the sheer taboo of it, just because it's another way for them to push the envelope. They might chance it and act on those fantasies on their own. They will generally take the bait if it's sincerely offered.
Having a good girl Ash bump into this subject, and tangle with it and maybe warm up to it, is one thing. But for good Ash to be the one chasing this, and bad Ash to not just skip it, but act outraged.. It doesn't add up bro.