V2 was pretty bad. Clearly gyaru-inspired, which kinda does translate into white trash when done in manga/anime style. Since I know how gyaru look like in real life, that also makes me dislike it further.
V3 is at least better, but V1 is clearly a more stylish girl focusing on sex-appeal. That version also makes sense when considering Asami's transformation. V2 or V3 may serve better in Natsume's own backstory, but their styles are completely different from the one Asami ends up with, that it makes no sense she'd recommend clothes like that.
If Natsume is meant to come from a poor family, explaining the trashy style, then I don't see a big problem using V1. Her more expensive/classier clothes could be explained as being bought by Minato or whatever that guy's name was.