VN Ren'Py Grandma's House [Part 5 v0.73] [Moonbox]

3.70 star(s) 320 Votes
Discussion Reviews (320)
SlapE

SlapE

Well-Known Member
Dec 4, 2022
1,862
5,260
I see the Melissa theories and discussion has sparked up again... oh boy, these won't stop until the end of the game or until she's confirmed dead or alive, which could be in 20-30 updates. :LOL:

MoonBox will just keep fueling the fire too, all while he rubs his hands together and laughs maniacally.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: CircaAD, Elhemeer and kcaldw
xapican

xapican

Devoted Member
May 11, 2020
10,618
16,108
What Melissa theory's we got let's sumarize a bit,
  1. Pene del Diablo's Alien abduction, which would explain the Supersperm.........
  2. Fat Giant's : She is alive but not discoverd yet.........
  3. Mine,: It's Tanya, and Tanyas archiconservative parents are Fosters.......
Did I miss some ?
Edit: giving this all a thought over, another suitable candidate would be Isabella, since she is Orphan, and about Cat's age .....like Fat Giant pointed out in one post.
Nª4 Isabella
 
Last edited:
  • Thinking Face
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: AhleWoscht, Elhemeer, FatGiant and 1 other person
Elhemeer

Elhemeer

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 20, 2022
6,675
11,102
xapican said:
What Melissa theory's we got let's sumarize a bit,
  1. Pene del Diablo's Alien abduction, which would explain the Supersperm.........
  2. Fat Giant's : She is alive but not discoverd yet.........
  3. Mine,: It's Tanya, and Tanyas archiconservative parents are Fosters.......
Did I miss some ?
Edit: giving this all a thought over, another suitable candidate would be Isabella, since she is Orphan, and about Cat's age .....like Fat Giant pointed out in one post.
Nª4 Isabella
Click to expand...
Considering that Tanya has already been tagged as a Nana-clone, that's one of the better theories in my opinion.

I think Isabella falls into the same ethnic blockade as Maria though ...
 
  • Like
Reactions: eltharion83
Uthuriel

Uthuriel

Conversation Conqueror
Jan 26, 2021
6,889
21,544
Elhemeer said:
Considering that Tanya has already been tagged as a Nana-clone, that's one of the better theories in my opinion.

I think Isabella falls into the same ethnic blockade as Maria though ...
Click to expand...
I think it's Shawna. We haven't heard or seen anything from her since the beginning.
We don't know her real hair color because it was dyed blue when we met her. She has piercings and tats. All those obfuscate her natural appearance.

I think she could be the missing sister.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: AhleWoscht, kcaldw, xapican and 1 other person
E

eltharion83

Member
Aug 24, 2020
238
475
Uthuriel said:
I think it's Shawna. We haven't heard or seen anything from here since the beginning.
We don't know her real hair color because it was dyed blue when we met her. She has piercings and tats. All those obfuscate her natural appearance.

I think she could be the missing sister.
Click to expand...
She would be the most plausible one so far, I agree with you on that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Uthuriel
FatGiant

FatGiant

Forum Fanatic
Jan 7, 2022
5,490
17,521
Uthuriel said:
I think it's Shawna. We haven't heard or seen anything from her since the beginning.
We don't know her real hair color because it was dyed blue when we met her. She has piercings and tats. All those obfuscate her natural appearance.

I think she could be the missing sister.
Click to expand...
Age is wrong. Sorry!

The thing is, Melissa is "probably" dead. All this may be just a mirage. I just can't deny that it is a plot point that is extremely attractive. Not only because the MC recovers his sister, Nana recovers another grand daughter, Amy & Liz a niece and Cat a very close cousin. It also means that the tragedy of the disaster wasn't complete, that there's still a small chance to reduce the harm.

This, is all probably futile and it is all based on what could very well be on a wrong interpretation of the disaster description. It may not even be on MB's intentions to launch a mystery. YET. I can't shake this impression. I simply can't. And the fact that I don't know why, is what irks me the most.

Peace :)
 
  • Like
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: AhleWoscht, kcaldw, xapican and 2 others
Elhemeer

Elhemeer

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 20, 2022
6,675
11,102
FatGiant said:
Age is wrong. Sorry!

The thing is, Melissa is "probably" dead. All this may be just a mirage. I just can't deny that it is a plot point that is extremely attractive. Not only because the MC recovers his sister, Nana recovers another grand daughter, Amy & Liz a niece and Cat a very close cousin. It also means that the tragedy of the disaster wasn't complete, that there's still a small chance to reduce the harm.

This, is all probably futile and it is all based on what could very well be on a wrong interpretation of the disaster description. It may not even be on MB's intentions to launch a mystery. YET. I can't shake this impression. I simply can't. And the fact that I don't know why, is what irks me the most.

Peace :)
Click to expand...
Honestly, I thought MB was definitely dropping an intentional breadcrumb with the sister's body not being found.

That said, there are a few potential scenarios regardless of that assumption.
  1. The statement was a Red Herring and Melissa was always meant to be dead.
  2. The statement is, in fact, a clue to be brought up eventually (maybe part of that second-half content).
  3. The statement WAS a clue, but — like Elaine — has become a plot point cast aside (the reason being irrelevant).
  4. Not only is the statement a clue, but there is, in fact, an imposter among the crewmates. There are a few candidates. There is no OBVIOUS candidate though, and any that turned out to be Melissa would probably have to have some retconning of their story to fit the mold (For instance, despite my enthusiastic response earlier in the thread, Tanya would have to be a few years younger than she seems to think she is to fit the bill) I, myself, can't think of anyone in the cast with a completely ambiguous past that is a realistic candidate.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: FatGiant and kcaldw
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
3.70 star(s) 320 Votes