You didn't see anything, part 2 is so bad that even the CGs aren't worth it. I felt deeply insulted by that comparison, it even hurt. I hope N_Taii doesn't read this. NTR Online is really bad, and part 2 is trash. I only follow it because of my MILF Kyoko.
I haven't read all the previous discussions, but for me, only Cyanna did things that I think crossed the line. Rose is the most delicate situation, but it's still palpable. Her mind is in a terrible state. I always say that Rose and Lily's kisses with semen are unforgivable (they are), but Cyanna was the only one who betrayed Leto in both senses (send her to the guillotine).
Of course, the way Rose was treating Leto as an obstacle in the last update is up for discussion.
I see I’m not the only one who felt insulted by that comparison, it honestly shouldn’t even exist.
As for the girls in
HC3, I already told N_Taii that it would be extremely difficult to have a satisfying ending after everything they’ve done. I totally agre, the semen-filled kiss scene is unforgivable. Just thinking about it disgusts me, lol.
It reminds me of a game called
A Promise Best Left Unkept, where the MC literally dives between his girlfriend’s legs and sucks the bull’s semen out of her so none remains inside. That was easily one of the most revolting scenes I’ve ever seen in an NTR game but at least in that case, it was intentional on the MC’s part.
Here though, I doubt Leto would be thrilled to find out his mouth is full of his enemies’ “sausage juice.”
I don’t really remember any act of betrayal from Cyanna, though it’s possible I skimmed through some dialogues too quickly. From what I recall, everything she did was meant to protect Leto. She was abused by Rudolph several times but didn’t fight back because she eventually derived pleasure from it.
Rose, on the other hand, took part in some truly disturbing scenes, covered in toys and vibrators, even giving a handjob or blowjob to an old man at one point. That final foursome scene with the duke left her completely humiliated. I genuinely thought the only thing she would manage to “save” for Leto was her backside, but no, she gave that to the duke as well. At that point, she has nothing left to offer him. It’s like a second-hand car, except worse—after the duke was done with her, her “mileage counter” skyrocketed. If I were Leto, I don’t think I could ever forgive that. I doubt he even knows everything she’s done in the true ending, because if he saw it all, I can’t imagine him forgiving her.
Even if he were to catch her in the act, no matter the reason, things could never be pure again. She’s been defiled, and all her firsts were taken by another man. Even for her, that would be unbearable, because every time she’s intimate with Leto, she’ll remember that the duke was her first in everything. If she can endure that, good for her, but I don’t think Leto could forgive such a betrayal. His rage would be immense, enough to justify a revenge ending.
I could imagine the succubus showing him how every woman betrayed him, convincing him that they can’t be trusted, corrupting him until he becomes worse than the duke himself.
Of course, I’m not in favor of another “revenge shell” ending like in
HC2, where the MC is just an empty husk. I’ve already discussed that with N_Taii, and I respect his view that the revenge ending isn’t meant to heal the wounds—that’s what the “happy ending” is for. It’s called “happy” only because it’s the non-canonical, most positive outcome, but in reality it’s more like a bandage. There’s no miracle recovery—you can’t just go back to the innocence of the first game.
In the latest update, Cyanna does everything Ulrod tells her to do, claiming it’s to protect her brother Leto. Ulrod even tells her she’s changed—that she obeys not because she loves him but because she’s broken. She justifies it by saying she’s already done worse, and if it means saving her brother, any sacrifice is worth it. At this point, seeing the foursome scene that follows, she’s basically an empty shell. Ulrod doesn’t even need to corrupt her anymore—he’s already succeeded.
Even so, Cyanna still holds Leto in the highest regard and knows his heart belongs to Rose. Since she’s seen Rose with the duke, maybe that also affected her—perhaps she feels that what she’s doing isn’t as bad in comparison. And honestly, she’s not wrong; after everything she’s been through with Ulrod, what he asks of her in that last scene is nothing in comparison.
To make her redemption believable, there should be a scene where Ulrod needs her for something, but she chooses Leto instead—maybe stabbing Ulrod in the back when he tries to kill Leto. He’d be shocked, asking why she chose Leto over him, and she’d finally tell him she never loved him and only endured him for her brother’s sake. Watching Ulrod suffer in that moment would be incredibly satisfying.
When you face scumbags like the duke, Ulrod, Jason, or the old men with Lily, you can’t help but think about how many lives they’ve ruined—they’re unforgivable. For the “happy ending,” I hope they don’t die quickly; they should suffer until their last breath. Killing them would be too kind—they should be castrated and forced to work in the mines to serve the nation they disgraced.
I’d love to see endings where the roles are reversed, and everyone begs Leto for forgiveness while the player gets to choose their fate.
Honestly, I don’t think the “happy ending” has to be like
HC2. I can’t imagine Leto being truly happy, even with a harem of women defiled by other men. There can’t be any “magic moments” left between them, those were stolen. All their first times are gone, taken by others. For some people that might not matter, but considering they were literally violated and forced to do those things, it’s hard to imagine genuine love after that.
What makes it worse is that they actually climaxed with those men, no need to fake it. I’ve never met a woman who could orgasm with someone she doesn’t love. Imagine being forced to sleep with someone you don’t even like, doing it against your will for the sake of someone you care about, it’s unthinkable. Personally, I have to give credit to Rose and Lily for being able to endure it and still look Leto in the eyes afterwards.
I couldn’t do it myself. The weight of that betrayal would crush me, I’d confess everything right away. So honestly, props to the girls. Really.
